Do You Still Think Ronson Was The Best Choice?

[Lassex 1,169]

I'm sure someone is going to take this in a wrong way, but no, he wasn't the best choice in my opinion. He's surely legendary and daddy material ( ) but his sound doesn't really excite me. But this is completely subjective - if you asked me if he was the right choice to execute Gaga's plans, I'd say yes. I'm sure this is what she wanted and I'm glad that she followed her heart with the album. Like the others said, he was probably the best choice considering the genre.

[donutellha 13,819]

For the analog aesthetics of Joanne, yes, by far the best. But the instrumentation still feels wonky, and that might not be on Gaga's part

(yes, I was rooting for more kavin parker influence because have you've HEARD his iconic basslines?)

[Not The Real Gaga 7,349]

Thank you for all the votes!

 

[Reality 66,907]

He was the best choice, and personally, I think he's one of the best producers for Gaga.

They have a certain chemistry that we haven't necessarily seen with any other producer, and I think that's pretty evident through the music.

While I love RedOne and DJWS and the music she's made with them, I don't want her to stick to just a couple of producers. Gaga's always going to evolve and change, you know, maybe she'll make more music with Ronson, maybe she'll move on. 

I'm not going to get pressed, and neither should anyone else just because she's decided to work with someone else. I swear, I see some people feel so offended by the fact that she worked/is working with Ronson. I've see some people say that she's "betrayed" RedOne and thrown him to the side.

That's complete and utter bullsh*t, sorry not sorry. It was an artistic decision to work with Ronson and we have to learn to respect that. 

[mic 1,385]

It doesnt matter. Its rather how the material is delivered. We got snooze fest while we could have 2 slay eras already with DH and DIC with perfect performances and videos. But no she prefers to sing boring ballad in the grass. Then it doesn't matter if it's RedOne, Ronson or whoever really

[Slade 2,591]

Absolutely. I hope they work together again.

[RochestrMonstr 2,284]

Absolutely perfect. I'm sure she'll switch it up again next time like she always does, but he did a great job with her on Joanne. 

[takemetovenus 4,826]

for the LG5 I wanted, no.

for the LG5 we got, definitely yes.

[Rockets 1,807]

I love the album and Gaga seems so so proud of the work they've done, so yeah it was the best choice cause the music is good and she's happy

[Bellatrix 34,639]

Totally! 

[littlepotter 73,282]

I actually wasn't thrilled when I heard he replaced RedOne, but now  I'm SO glad it happened!

[Born Brave 2,072]

Hmm. right now yes I think he was the best choice. But the album has barely been out a month. 

 

When ARTPOP came out I loved it, but gradually, I began to see how cheap it was from a production standpoint. You can't say that about Joanne. ARTPOP is like a pair of crocs- they are comfortable in your own home but if you wear them in public people look at you like WTF?? Joanne is opposite. You can play Joanne to anyone and they won't ask you "what is she singing about??" 

I think the organic sound was a move in the right direction. 

[littlepotter 73,282]

39 minutes ago, Justinn said:

Hmm. right now yes I think he was the best choice. But the album has barely been out a month. 

 

When ARTPOP came out I loved it, but gradually, I began to see how cheap it was from a production standpoint. You can't say that about Joanne. ARTPOP is like a pair of crocs- they are comfortable in your own home but if you wear them in public people look at you like WTF?? Joanne is opposite. You can play Joanne to anyone and they won't ask you "what is she singing about??" 

I think the organic sound was a move in the right direction. 

[Arizona Sky 10,913]

Yes he was  

[RAMROD 98,663]

Yes, no regret.

The album is really good. 

Don't confuse quality with popularity.