Joanne adds review on Metacritic; NOW Magazine gives Joanne 40/100

[Manul 7,377]

1 hour ago, SpaceAce said:

We're not giving him attention. He's written a review in a major, albeit local, publication - he already has all of the attention. Responding to it with accurate criticisms isn't the same thing as feeding trolls or random internet haters. 

Im sure he'll check GGD to see what y'all think

[Fizzy 2,217]

atlas it didn't affect the score  

Kevin Ritchie can suck Gaga's donkey ****

[SpaceAce 1,058]

2 minutes ago, Mood Ring said:

Im sure he'll check GGD to see what y'all think

So your problem is...? First you say don't give him any attention and now you're acknowledging we're not because this is a discussion on a fan forum? Do I need to remind you that forums are where discussions take place and opinions are exchanged?

Very strange.

[SomethingMore 1,701]

the thing is, without this review the album was very close to 69. Like 68.4 (0.1 away) and now this review probably pushed it down to 67.6 or something like that  

[TopDomBoy 1,182]

Gaga will never get the critics on her side, so.... 

[Katie14 4,828]

I really don't understand how anyone can call this album bad. Even if the style isn't someone's taste, her vocals, instrumentation, and melodies are still good quality and that should be recognized. I mean, I don't like a lot of rock music but I can still recognize when a rock song is good in terms of musical quality, even if I don't personally enjoy the sound. 

I don't understand how these critic's minds work