Italian Joanne Reviews Thread

[KarmaPolice 4,716]

Hi monsters! Since Italian reviews are coming I've decided to group them together instead of opening multiple threads (mods can close the other threads). So here they are:

Rockol.it
http://www.rockol.it/recensioni-musicali/album/6610/lady-gaga-joanne

Very positive review! 4/5 Stars!

RTL.it
http://www.rtl.it/notizie/articoli/lady-gaga-joanne-e-il-coraggio-di-essere-se-stessa/

The title is "Lady Gaga, Joanne e the courage of being herself!"
Another positive review! Her voice before everything else for a well produced, balanced album!

Tgcom24.mediaset.it
http://www.tgcom24.mediaset.it/spettacolo/lady-gaga-in-joanne-si-spoglia-di-tutte-le-maschere-per-brillare-di-piu_3037549-201602a.shtml

The title is "Lady Gaga on Joanne drops her mask to shine even more"
Gaga shows the courage and strengh to put out an album good as this one.

Wired.it 
http://www.wired.it/play/musica/2016/10/19/joanne-rehab-musicale-lady-gaga-passa-country/

The title is "Joanne: Gaga's musical rehab goes through country"
He loves the upbeat songs and he says that even the slow tempos find their own identities. He says that the album is excellent, choesive and made to showcase her vocal and musical talent. He concludes that the album is quite a step back for Gaga (in the sense to being back to her roots) in a foward direction. He also mentions Angel Down quoting "I confess I am lost / In the age of the social" in relation to the fact that the craziness of her persona was about to "eat" her, and with this album she's trying to escape it. 
The only mixed point is that he fears that the album is more like an emergency in order to stop the craziness that surrounded her instead of a real growth. 

Foruzine.it
http://www.fourzine.it/2016/10/19/joanne-lanima-profonda-di-lady-gaga-recensione/

The title is "Joanne: Gaga's deep soul"
He praised the album to heaven, saying is choesive and it sounds nothing like anything that's on the radio right now, the fact that she displays her raw voice and so on.
He says Million Reasons it's her BEST SONG to date.

IlFattoQuotidiano.it
http://www.ilfattoquotidiano.it/2016/10/20/lady-gaga-con-joanne-dimostra-ancora-una-volta-di-essere-la-popostar-assoluta-del-nuovo-millennio/3110082/

The title is "With Joanne, Gaga shows once again that she's the ultimate post start of the millennium"
It's an all praise article, I'll just report the last sentence: "Joanne is set to be a classic modern piece of music"  


 

[TopDomBoy 1,182]

Italians do it better. 

[Jester 6,198]

Joanne indeed is Gaga's profound soul

 

[jinko 5,427]

16 minutes ago, Tommi said:

Wired.it 
http://www.wired.it/play/musica/2016/10/19/joanne-rehab-musicale-lady-gaga-passa-country/
"Joanne: Gaga's musical rehab goes through country"

He also mentions Angel Down quoting "I confess I am lost / In the age of the social" in relation to the fact that the craziness of her persona was about to "eat" her, and with this album she's trying to escape it. The only mixed point is that he fears that the album is more like an emergency in order to stop the craziness that surrounded her instead of a real growth. 

 

A very profound review  I'm impressed he got this deep. What should one do to get this kind of a review in America? Some "critics" there are more focused on comparing Gaga's and Florence's voices on a song that discourages competition among women. 

[display name 4,360]

So these reviewers are actually listening to and discussing the songs!?!?!?  

When will the metacritic ATRLers?  

[Reality 66,042]

Queen of Italian reviews

[SEXODUS 5,920]

Of course she'd get good reviews, guys. She's Italian. 

[KarmaPolice 4,716]

16 minutes ago, SEXODUS said:

Of course she'd get good reviews, guys. She's Italian. 

Tell that to the old sis ARTPOP. She was dragged to hell here for that :V

[SEXODUS 5,920]

5 minutes ago, Tommi said:

Tell that to the old sis ARTPOP. She was dragged to hell here for that :V

I was, in fact, joking. 

My Twitter account is full of italian peeps expressing their pagan critiques.

[KarmaPolice 4,716]

Just now, SEXODUS said:

I was, in fact, joking. 

My Twitter account is full of italian peeps expressing their pagan critiques.

Ofc it was a joke, I was just saying that Joanne being recieved so positively is indeed a good thing!

[Rockets 1,807]

Omg I'm so happy that my country is stanning for Slayanne 

She should come here and perform at X Factor live shows, it would be awesome, maybe she could be the super guest for the Finale 

[StarstruckIllusion 42,553]

It'd be nice if you actually inputted the scores, out of ten, instead of leaving me to bust each site 

[KarmaPolice 4,716]

7 minutes ago, ChaosAngelX69 said:

It'd be nice if you actually inputted the scores, out of ten, instead of leaving me to bust each site 

Your fingers must hurt, right? Geez some people here are so rude...I mean, I've translated parts of the reviews and posted them here and you come out with that?

There are no scores.

[StarstruckIllusion 42,553]

7 minutes ago, Tommi said:

Your fingers must hurt, right? Geez some people here are so rude...I mean, I've translated parts of the reviews and posted them here and you come out with that?

There are no scores.

Sis if I actually gave you a good reason to be offended, I'd have already cussed you out lmao. chill. I didn't know scores weren't a factor here-they usually are. 

[KarmaPolice 4,716]

2 minutes ago, ChaosAngelX69 said:

Sis if I actually gave you a good reason to be offended, I'd have already cussed you out lmao. chill. I didn't know scores weren't a factor here-they usually are. 

You acted like a spoiled child, like I didn't do my work correctly just because you HAD to click on THREE link to see if there was a score.