What Critics Have To Say About Gaga's Albums

[FinnishGypsy 921]

2 hours ago, Slade said:

I wish they'd take those stupid remix albums off of her Metacritic profile so her overall score would be higher. 

I've been a stan since TF and literally didn't know those existed until right now. 

[Leeo 2,366]

Ok I don't get if the critics were bad or whatever nnn

the "Tiny mix Tape" was the one that gave a 0 to Born This Way nnnnnnnnnnnnn

 

And ARTPOP still with a Green note so whatever 

 

[venusfly 17,885]

1 minute ago, FinnishGypsy said:

I've been a stan since TF and literally didn't know those existed until right now. 

The Remix is one of the highest selling remix albums of all time because everyone thought it was a new album  it sold like 500,000 copies 

[Leeo 2,366]

2 hours ago, Slade said:

I wish they'd take those stupid remix albums off of her Metacritic profile so her overall score would be higher. 

 

omg IKR and it's so unfair if u check the critics cuz it's like... 4 critics on the fking messy album.

[FinnishGypsy 921]

8 hours ago, FATCAT said:

It pains me that BTW has a lower score than TFM. Like, They're both deserve a 70+, but BTW is so versatile and long.

I think the versatility and length are precisely the problems; TFM is arguably her most cohesive album and has zero fillers. I also adore BTW, but it would've fared much better critically if it wasn't so experimental sonically; this is bound to polarize listeners. Also, "Bad Kids" is definitely an unnecessary filler, IMO.