Isn't It Bad That π Doesnt Sound Like Joanne?

[StarstruckIllusion 52,473]

Like isn't that messy? I'm thinking that if someone from the GP likes it, they'd be disappointed by Joanne bc Gaga said PI isn't indicative of Joanne… but if someone hates Perfect Illusion, then they wouldn't even wanna give it a listen. Stupid, I know.

I know it's gonna flop disasterously either way, so it's not a chart thing, I was just thinking that it was interesting that she has released an outlier on the album as the lead . 

[Gardevoir 9,822]

Just now, ChaosAngelX69 said:

Like isn't that messy? I'm thinking that if someone from the GP likes it, they'd be disappointed by Joanne bc Gaga said PI isn't indicative of Joanne… but if someone hates Perfect Illusion, then they wouldn't wanna even listen. 

I know it's gonna flop disasterously either way, so it's not a chart thing, I was just thinking that it was interesting that she has released an outlier on the album . 

[CLLGaga 928]

No. It's GOOD. If the rest of the album is as bad as PI I'd burn my stan card. 

[StarstruckIllusion 52,473]

Just now, Emigrante said:

Wow. A GIF. So additive to the convo, I totally understand what you're saying 

[iAstroLeo 14,424]

 

[Bear 7,515]

I don't think it's going to be that much of an outlier despite what she said. I think she said that more to give hope to the fans who hated PI. 

[REALITY 76,251]

We haven't heard any other song from the album yet, though. Yeah, she said that PI isn't indicative of Joanne—which is sort of a given because it's Kevin Parker's only song (if I'm not mistaken), and PI was originally his idea—but we just can't really tell know because we haven't heard anything since. 

[Evan Peters 10,738]

uhm.

[Gardevoir 9,822]

5 minutes ago, ChaosAngelX69 said:

Like isn't that messy? I'm thinking that if someone from the GP likes it, they'd be disappointed by Joanne bc Gaga said PI isn't indicative of Joanne… but if someone hates Perfect Illusion, then they wouldn't even wanna give it a listen. Stupid, I know.

I know it's gonna flop disasterously either way, so it's not a chart thing, I was just thinking that it was interesting that she has released an outlier on the album as the lead . 

*

[Computer 10,973]

I think pi and joane will sound more like each other than all her other songs.

But there will be some variety and im excited about that.

[DeleteMyAccount 11,881]

I'm confused by that statement. Will PI stick out then? 

[Sylvanas 5,768]

[Redstreak 6,653]

1 minute ago, ZacharyMark said:

I'm confused by that statement. Will PI stick out then? 

I think they're asking was it a bad idea to make PI the first taste of Joanne if it apparently doesn't sound like the rest of the album.

[Swan Heart 7,382]

Well, it probably doesn't sound like the rest of the album in a way similar to how Born This Way doesn't sound like Heavy Metal Lover or Bloody Mary.

[artRaver 3,188]

According to you if it's going to flop either way why do you care if it reflects on Joanne as a whole or not?  

 

For the meanwhile though I'm just going to go by what she said on Twitter so I don't have a certain expectation in which direction she's going with.

If that's the case it doesn't matter what she would've made as a single if they're apparently each different in some way or sort. I'm sure they all fit together though.