Jump to content
question

Has PI received critical acclaim?


Thomas P

Featured Posts

Thomas P
3 minutes ago, Supersonic said:

The only outlets that criticized it were Pitchfork & The Guardian (The review from the Guardian was a mess though because the journalist is an obvious Britney Spears stan, criticized Gaga's vocal performance and lauded Britney's on Glory)

Outlets that have reviewed positively were:

New York Post
NME
LA Times
Digital Spy

All of those previously dragged Gaga.

Other positives were from:

The Daily Telegraph
Billboard
Idolator
The Independant
The Needle Drop
 

Can we even call pitchfork an actually review though? It was stupid conversation that needed some serious spell check and editing to be done. It was lazy, so just because of that I don't consider it to be real.

I’m a simple guy to please, if you like Melodrama, we chill.
Link to post
Share on other sites

  • Replies 48
  • Created
  • Last Reply
RadioIsOurs
1 minute ago, LG said:

Neither of those sites are considered major critics that get noted

I mean the reviews that are quoted in the page itself. 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Supersonic
1 minute ago, Thomas P said:

Can we even call pitchfork an actually review though? It was stupid conversation that needed some serious spell check and editing to be done. It was lazy, so just because of that I don't consider it to be real.

Tbh I don't think they'll even give an actual review of it. Maybe they will see the light soon and realize that Perfect Illusion is a grower and not a shower.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Thomas P
1 minute ago, Supersonic said:

Tbh I don't think they'll even give an actual review of it. Maybe they will see the light soon and realize that Perfect Illusion is a grower and not a shower.

I don't mind if it gets negative reviews, I just got mad because of how lazy and stupid the one they gave was.

I’m a simple guy to please, if you like Melodrama, we chill.
Link to post
Share on other sites

9 minutes ago, RainbowBlonde said:

Found more than just Guardian who talked **** about her...

http://www.inquisitr.com/3497193/lady-gagas-perfect-illusion-receives-mixed-reviews-and-several-madonna-comparisons/

https://www.queerty.com/need-talk-lady-gagas-new-single-perfect-illusion-20160909

I'm not trying to be negative here, but saying that ALL critics love it is kinda delusional IMO. 

Hun you're tryin to be negative everywhere because YOU don't like the song and cannot move on it... so stop talkin' s***..

:nails:

TONIGHT I WON'T WEAR MY DISGUISE
Link to post
Share on other sites

RadioIsOurs
Just now, Gangie said:

Hun you're tryin to be negative everywhere because YOU don't like the song and cannot move on it... so stop talk s***..

:nails:

My opinion is irrelevant here. I'm trying to point out what I've found.

Unless you want me to go '"Omg everyone praised it it's going to be the best reviewed song in the world!!"...

Link to post
Share on other sites

The song is getting critical acclaim, but that Guardian review overshadows the other rational reviews from smaller outlets. It isn't fair.

You don't deserve a point of view if the only thing you see is you.
Link to post
Share on other sites

But who cares about if a critic thinks a song is right or wrong? Hell if Gaga wanted a Perfect score, team would just pay them.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Lextyr97

Wikipedia is 95% accurate and that's a fact. I hate when professors say it's not reliable :madge: It is. Don't believe what those other pieces of **** say. Every single thing added to Wikipedia needs to be backed up by sources. So it's pretty accurate.

Link to post
Share on other sites

11 minutes ago, RainbowBlonde said:

My opinion is irrelevant here. I'm trying to point out what I've found.

Unless you want me to go '"Omg everyone praised it it's going to be the best reviewed song in the world!!"...

Honey, I'm not just talking about this thread but overall ... 

OT: PI is acclaimed at all but it is Gaga so you know, even if 'Imagine' was her song she probably would be also dragged for it so it's predictable that not every review will be positive.

TONIGHT I WON'T WEAR MY DISGUISE
Link to post
Share on other sites

RadioIsOurs
Just now, Gangie said:

Honey, I'm not just talking about this thread but overall ... 

Negative as in stating my opinion? Maybe I've said that one too many times but...

Being negative = saying it deserves to flop and that everyone liking it is delusional

Link to post
Share on other sites

BurqaSwg
2 minutes ago, RainbowBlonde said:

Negative as in stating my opinion? Maybe I've said that one too many times but...

Being negative = saying it deserves to flop and that everyone liking it is delusional

is that sarcasm? 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


×
×
  • Create New...