If Gaga recorded the fake Pefect Illusion (ma pa pa) would it be a hit?

[Gagas love 722]

3 minutes ago, calmar said:

There definitely would have been more tweaks; the song as is doesn't sound Gaga at all. The harmonies in the final chorus are atrocious, the bridge is bad, the lyrics are to some degree elementary (all perfect rhymes with 'illusion' instead of the off-rhymes Gaga often employs) and sometimes don't make sense (looked like Fred Astaire? Yes, that was a C2C thing but Fred Astaire was a dancer, not a looker). Even the verses are the same as the chorus in melody.

The hook is also, like I've mentioned in a few other threads, reductive of Money Honey. 

it sounds like a demo, demos arent supposed to be grammy worthy

[calmar 22,064]

Just now, Gagas love said:

it sounds like a demo, demos arent supposed to be grammy worthy

The creator and distributor of the fake song has not to my knowledge claimed that it is a demo. Demos skill have the bare bones of harmony and melody in place in many, many cases. Sometimes parts are added or removed, or switched around (think the Bad Romance demo or MANiCURE early version from September 2013); but the essence of the song is already there.

Some further criticism of the fake song:

- The synth simply mirrors the the vocals; it doesn't nothing of its own, like establish a tonality.
- The singer needs practice to sound good without that much autotuning. 

[vertigostick 2,448]

It's absolutely AWFUL, should be locked, deleted and burnt. Period.

[Dangerous Man 9,245]

No, it belongs to Britney Jean

[ReidOne 12,427]

18 minutes ago, Gagas love said:

I think she actually created it and released it to throw everyone off

Honestly, I suspect this, too! 

[BlaqJezus 1,027]

Let me see, catchy but mediocre rehash of like 5 songs you have heard before...so yeah, it would probably be number one.

[Guest]

tbh i have heard it so many times by clicking on leak videos that it has been stuck in my head. It's silly af but we can say yes it's very catchy! Like Rihanna's stupid -chicken clucking- song 'Wo-wo-wo -wo work'!