Would you still stan for Gaga if she wasn't such a good live singer?

[SirLudicopro 1,351]

Personally, I think I would, but it would be kind of... different. I mean, she has my favorite discography out of any artist I know, she is very kind-hearted, she is a great activist and an amazing person in general, but... what if she was just an average or a bad live singer? What if she even *gasp* lip-synced? 

I think I would still stan for her, but I feel like it just wouldn't be the same, I wouldn't look up her performances on YouTube and be amazed, I wouldn't proudly show them to friends...

What do you think sisters? Discuss 

[Amatoxina 689]

Probably, as an artist, maybe, but I don't think she would lip-sync, she probably wouldn't sing if she knew her voice wasn't great or something but she would be an amazing actress anyway 

[Luc 4,775]

No. The acoustic videos and tour performances really made me get into her.

[WORLDofGAGA 2,274]

I'd still be a fan as she has so many other good things I love about her! But I wouldn't be so blown away by her performances and her dancing at same time knowing she's lip syncing, plus her tour wouldn't be so good knowing that! To be fair her voice and talent is one of her best qualities and one that many artists of today don't have. Here for Gaga  voice or no voice.✌🏼️

[SlaeUrAnus 15,970]

Yes. It was her artistry and fierce attitude that made me a stan.

[Fernster7 7,922]

Well I believe I would still be a stan but not in the same way, I would obviously enjoy her songs, videos and praise her for her personality and kindness, that's something I admire in every person. 

I just would not have the same respect, wouldn't look up her performances or be extremely excited when a new one is about to happen. And wouldn't care if people think she's bad.

[Hexxx 2,244]

Sure i will, but something's off about her melody now when she's singing live now and it makes me cringe. As long as she put on a good performance she can keep my Stan card

[Sorcerer 12,507]

I would be probably just be a random stan. Like when she releases good music, I'll like it. Just like how I like KP's, TS' and others' songs. But not how I even join a cult site for her. 

 

[Bradley 59,150]

I do love Britney and Rihanna... so yes.

[OmgSum1Actually 3,041]

yes

[djBuffoon 12,123]

It would be a huge let-down, that's for sure.

[Fiona Apple 13,006]

I'd still like her music a lot (I listen to Rihanna,Britney etc.) but I probably wouldn't really stan because her acoustic performances made me a fan at first and then I started to appriciate her weirdness,her music videos and her dance songs

[Mr Judas 4,106]

She wouldn't be where she is right now tbh, and I don't know if she would have even got past the 'one-hit-wonder' category 

She is right now known for being an eccentric pop star that can fvckng kill careers with her live performances. 

[Haroon 49,685]

Yeah I still would  I became a fan before I knew she had a great set of pipes on her, although they definitely do make me like her even more because they've made for some amazing performances that are just about her voice and her piano  

[brendablethyn 536]

No. I'm here for talent and the music. I could never stan for an artist that wasn't highly skilled in their field, regardless of if it was singing or painting or furniture making.