Jump to content
opinion

Elton John Is Wrong. ARTPOP Is Not a Bad Album


Quark

Featured Posts

monketsharona

Gaga recognized herself that her involvement, her writing and her compositions weren't as good on ARTPOP as on any of her other albums mostly because she wasn't emotionally deeply focused on it... so I guess Elton is just confirming what Gaga is feeling about her own work on ARTPOP 

Link to post
Share on other sites

  • Replies 291
  • Created
  • Last Reply
PunkTheFunk

I absolutely love the songs on ARTPOP individually but as a whole, it just never really worked for me. So I guess I kind of understand what Elton is saying when he thinks it was a 'bad album.' It just wasn't as cohesive or as deep as TF, TFM, and BTW. That's all.

08uve1

Link to post
Share on other sites

DiscoHeaven23

good and bad are subjective terms anyway, so its nothing to worry about. Elton John is one person.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Just now, monketsharona said:

Gaga recognized herself that her involvement, her writing and her compositions weren't as good on ARTPOP as on any of her other albums mostly because she wasn't emotionally deeply focused on it... so I guess Elton is just confirming what Gaga is feeling about her own work on ARTPOP 

When did she say this?

Link to post
Share on other sites

monketsharona
Just now, Enigma said:

When did she say this?

On that interview in Billboard, she kinda dissed ARTPOP

Link to post
Share on other sites

FameHookah

Idgaf about his opinion, ARTPOP shits all over BTW and TFM, if it did as bad it was because of the mess after mess since Gaga released alejandro..

 

Y'all should be blaming  BTW not ARTPOP

 

K im done

 

*deeph breaths*

WTF is MDNA
Link to post
Share on other sites

10 minutes ago, Twisted Shadows said:

Isn't Elton John entitled to his opinion as you are? Disagree? Different strokes, different folks. 

And that is exactly what I am doing, I am expressing my disagreement with his opinion and I stated why I disagree

Link to post
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, monketsharona said:

On that interview in Billboard, she kinda dissed ARTPOP

Give me the exact words she said. Or the link. You might be twisting them.

Link to post
Share on other sites

10 minutes ago, Enigma said:

If he thinks is bad than that is OK, is just that is seems a little suspicious that he is talking about it now, and he never said anything bad about the album during its time.

enigma, stop being insecure, just cause elton thinks its bad doesn't mean you cant bop to ARTPOP. there's nothing suspicious about him saying it now. gaga was having a hard time during 2013 and her friend saying that her album is crap back then would have been worse. 

ARTPOP "underperforming" has nothing to do with eltons opinion. stop being insecure and enjoy whatever you enjoy. 

Link to post
Share on other sites

SISTERV

It's a fantastic album that showcased Gaga's ability to take risk. But it is not her greatest work. It is trippy, delusional, fun, chaos. It's the first album though, where I felt like Gaga was no longer in on the joke, but truly an outsider. Respectable.

But I will warn her new and young fans that joined 2013- because they love ARTPOP:

Those of us that have been here know the feeling of expectation with a new Gaga album, and it means that something new is coming. She always recreates her sound. Don't be disappointed in LG5 when it sounds absolutely nothing like ARTPOP. She has always done this, and I feel like this next record will be her biggest contrast from a previous work yet. 

LG5 will be blindingly left field for y'all if you have any expectations. So don't! You will be butt hurt. Don't **** on the album if it's not what you expect because I guarantee that if it is something great and different....it will be weird for you at first. 

Give it time to understand her musical evolution with LG5. 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Whispering
9 minutes ago, monketsharona said:

On that interview in Billboard, she kinda dissed ARTPOP

And BTW, right? 

Link to post
Share on other sites

2 minutes ago, Yanko said:

enigma, stop being insecure, just cause elton thinks its bad doesn't mean you cant bop to ARTPOP. there's nothing suspicious about him saying it now. gaga was having a hard time during 2013 and her friend saying that her album is crap back then would have been worse. 

ARTPOP "underperforming" has nothing to do with eltons opinion. stop being insecure and enjoy whatever you enjoy. 

Like I said, if he really doesn't like the album than that is his opinion. But I am just stating why I degree with his opinion and why I think he is wrong. There really is nothing wrong about this.

Link to post
Share on other sites

chromaticka

ARTPOP is a bae, i sleep holding that precious album next to my heart 

I Met Lady Gaga On February 7th, 2016; Attended Superbowl 51 and Coachella 2017.
Link to post
Share on other sites

FATCAT
31 minutes ago, Bio said:

to me ARTPOP could be her best album with just a few adjustments. But it sure is better than Born This Way

:rip:

I re-read your post hoping I missed some sarcasm, but nope. You poor thing.

This kitten over here (meow)
Link to post
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


×
×
  • Create New...