Rating the main ladies of pop

[yASSsss 35,510]

1 hour ago, Didymus said:

1. Beyoncé (all-round impressive talent)
2. Nicole Scherzinger (best vocal performer in the pop industry)
3. Kylie Minogue (incredible voice and performance skill)
4. Madonna (all-round talent, but on #4 because of everything post-2009)
5. Rihanna (captivating & constantly reinvented output, unique voice)
6. Lady Gaga (all-round talent, but on #6 because of artistic inconsistency)

lol 

[Didymus 34,379]

4 minutes ago, yASSsss said:

lol 

Care to expand?

[yASSsss 35,510]

2 minutes ago, Didymus said:

Care to expand?

nope..ur list made me chuckle ..and i think you know why..but i don't want to argue so i'll just skip that part

[The Child 18,997]

1. Beyonce (She is the best performer right now)

2. Gaga (Gaga needs to bring back choreographies a la Judas to be #1)

3. Madonna (Queen Of Pop)

4. Rihanna (She needs to improve her dancing)

Special mention to:

Britney (she needs to bring her A game back)

Adele (Because yeah she has vocals but pop is about entertainment, I don't want to fall asleep watching a performance. Or maybe I'm just a heartless person who can't be moved by Adele's performances, although her performances were better during the 21 era.)

I didn't include:

Miley (she's a mess)

Taylor & Katy cause they don't entertain me a bit.

[Didymus 34,379]

8 minutes ago, yASSsss said:

nope..ur list made me chuckle ..and i think you know why..but i don't want to argue so i'll just skip that part

Not really.. if Katy was above Gaga I would've understood Is it about Rihanna?

Or about Gaga being so "low" She's not. She's below amazing people. And like I argued in the post, the list would've been 1. Beyoncé; 2. Madonna; 3. Lady Gaga if it weren't for inconsistency. That's not a bad place to be Beyoncé's higher because she excels in vocals, dancing and acting, Madonna's higher because of her amazing catalogue.

This isn't about whose music or career I enjoy the most. This is about who I think does the best job at being a pop artist.

[bayonse 6,525]

2 hours ago, Caesium said:

Not sure about Gaga being on the same level as Adele.

Gaga had much more impact than Adele 

sales are not everything

[NewUsername 11,000]

2 hours ago, Didymus said:

1. Beyoncé (all-round impressive talent)
2. Nicole Scherzinger (best vocal performer in the pop industry)
3. Kylie Minogue (incredible voice and performance skill)
4. Madonna (all-round talent, but on #4 because of everything post-2009)
5. Rihanna (captivating & constantly reinvented output, unique voice)
6. Lady Gaga (all-round talent, but on #6 because of artistic inconsistency)
Below: P!nk, Adele, Katy, Ariana,...

Meh, lemme not go further. This list would've been different if I could also include non-main ladies though, especially Allie X who I think is the most promising pop performer today.

Edit: This isn't about who I enjoy the most (Nicole's solo music is ghastly, but I still placed her so high because she is insanely talented vocally). This is about capability. And note how I placed Gaga higher than Adele pls

Gaga on 6? BYE.
Didymus toch

[Didymus 34,379]

Just now, Driezewies said:

Gaga on 6? BYE.
Didymus toch

She's above 95% percent of all people listed in the OP and I even placed her higher than Adele who occupied the top spot there Not so bad imo.

[Versace 7,876]

1 hour ago, ****Eliza said:

I'd put Gaga and Katy at number one as imo they are the undeniable pop queens (if you forget about Katheryn's talent and performing skills ).

Then I think Taylor Swift even though she is considered a newcomer in the pop scene, I've always thought that her older smashes have been heavily influenced by pop. Anyways, she dominates with every album, she makes entertaining videos and the music sounds great as well (not a big fan of her though).

Then Queen B, RiRi, P!nk and Justin Bieber in any order.

I don't know what Adele is doing at No. 1 though, she is a monster in terms of success and very talented but she is lacking in any other area and her pop culture impact is minimal.

But of course, personal opinions and all, I'll just up yours cause there are some real queens in there. 

OMG i died 

i thought this thread was gonna be us talking about the LADIES only 

and you mentioning JB , can't tell if that's shade 

[AIex 3,102]

P!nk and Kesha are mains? 

[Manul 7,377]

Just now, Versace said:

OMG i died 

i thought this thread was gonna be us talking about the LADIES only 

and you mentioning JB , can't tell if that's shade 

Are you implying that JB isn't a sassy *pop queen?

How dare you. 

[Illuminati 15,785]

How can Kesha be one of the main ladies if her career is like literally over 

[EdX 2,857]

1./2.  Lady Gaga

1./2.  Madonna

3. Beyonce

4. Janet Jackson

5. Shakira

6. Ariana Grande

7. Ellie Goulding

8. Rihanna

9. Kesha

10. Britney Spears

OTHERS, which count as "pop" on the charts etc. but don't count as pop artists for me.

1. Adele

2. Grimes

3. Lana Del Rey

4. Marina and The Diamonds

5. Charli XCX

 

 

[Fiona Apple 13,006]

1.Lady Gaga

2.Mother Monster

3.Stefani Germanotta

4.DerpGa

and 5.Mrs Italian

[Fiona Apple 13,006]

3 hours ago, Didymus said:

1. Beyoncé (all-round impressive talent)
2. Nicole Scherzinger (best vocal performer in the pop industry)
3. Kylie Minogue (incredible voice and performance skill)
4. Madonna (all-round talent, but on #4 because of everything post-2009)
5. Rihanna (captivating & constantly reinvented output, unique voice)
6. Lady Gaga (all-round talent, but on #6 because of artistic inconsistency)
Below: P!nk, Adele, Katy, Ariana,...

 

Rihanna above Gaga?