Billboard: @billboard: Madonna or Lady Gaga: sang "La Vie en Rose" better?

[Gohan 16,447]

Gorl, they can't be serious.

That's like asking, who actually can sing.

 

Dis, they're thirsty for visits and clicks on their website

 

 

 

 

[Bradley 59,173]

Wow Billboard sure knows how to ruin fanbases.

[ctherainbow 3,162]

After watching that vid, I could totally see Madonna as a camp counselor just chilling out with some kids around a fire and playing her uke.  

[Eros92 2,513]

lol at the Madge stans.

Gaga CLEARLY has the better voice. It's not an opinion. They are all pressed. 

[Bad Bromance 5,809]

What are their intentions? 

To embarrass Madge? How unprofessional of them. 

To start a fan war? How petty of them.

To get clicks? How desperate. 

IKR???  Like, this question shouldn't even be asked.  While I thought Madonna did a wonderful job with her rendition, she in no way comes close to Gaga's powerful and beautiful voice.  Gaga is a better vocalist.  Period!

[cd9904 193]

I'm so done with those articles. 

 

What's the point? Two different interpretations. It's not comparable. 

[aaronyoji 2,054]

Grace Jones did

thissssss! her version gets completely overlooked, but i think her version is best. its both breazy, has ease to it, but still powerful and dramatic when it needs to be. 

[VenusBlackStar 1,301]

either they trolling or trying to give tihty some promo

Either this or they're throwing THE MOST subtle shade at Grace Jones in light of some of those snippets of her memoir (she also covered the song).

 

[Bette Davis 12,742]

The Madonna hate is absurd  I guess Madonna brought it upon herself from this fanbase though by antagonizing Gaga so much.

[Sunday 2,183]

Ok y'know what ? I'm not even gonna say anything. That article just spoke for itself . BB you are tragic af.

 

the comments tho

[crisTEAne 21,059]

such a tragic comparison. obviously, gaga's version is way better. i don't have a problem with madonna's cover either, it was cute. but really?  

The Madonna hate is absurd  I guess Madonna brought it upon herself from this fanbase though by antagonizing Gaga so much.

yes, she did.