If BTW and AP were shortened to 10 tracks, which songs should be cut?

[Stephen 30,432]

It's actually easier for me to make them 8 songs each, much more cohesive imo:

Marry the Night, Born This Way, Judas, Scheiße, Bloody Mary, Heavy Metal Lover, You and I, The Edge of Glory.

Aura, Venus, G.U.Y., Sexxx Dreams, Do What U Want, ARTPOP, Gypsy, Applause.

[Gagadonna 10,801]

girl we r the same person

I thought you knew 

*boy

[VforVendetta 2,024]

The only Lady Gaga album (except TFM lol) that can be shortened that much imo is TF:

1. "Just Dance" 
2. "LoveGame"  
3. "Paparazzi"  
4. "Poker Face"  
5. "Beautiful, Dirty, Rich"  
6. "The Fame"  
7. "Paper Gangsta"  
8. "Brown Eyes"  
9. "I Like It Rough"  

10. "Disco Heaven"

It would be flawless that way, without all the fillers.

 

I'd never shorten BTW and AP that much though, an ideal shortening for them would be at 13 songs but even this would be difficult for BTW.

 

I'd remove the bonus tracks + HML from BTW

I'd remove JnD and Donatella from ARTPOP.

Both 13 tracks.

[AmenTheNight 1,088]

I did this like 10 times, but let me try again.

 

Born this way :

Marry the night

Born this way

Government Hooker

Judas

Scheisse

Bloody Mary

Black Jesus

Bad Kids/Electric Chapel (can't decide)

Heavy Metal Lover

The Edge Of Glory

 

ARTPOP :

Applause

Venus

Sexxx Dreams

Aura

Do What U Want

Guy

ARTPOP

Donatella

Mary Jane Holland

Gypsy

 

 

[The Child 18,997]

I can't at some of you cutting You and I and Eletric Chapel  The album needs the guitars of those songs. Besides, they have two of the best productions on the album. EC is one of the best made by DJWS.

 

You And I is ****.

[Pop Art 1,773]

-

[Born To Slay 10,996]

1. Marry the Night

2. Born This Way

3. Government Hooker

4. Judas

5. Hair

6. Scheiße

7. Bloody Mary

8. Heavy Metal Lover

9. Yoü and I

10. The Edge of Glory

I'm not touching my baby, ARTPOP, though. That one actually needed more songs in my opinion.

I agre about ARTPOP, it would've been great if it were longer. The could've added on Temple, Tea, Red Flame, Brooklyn Nights, etc.

[Dominic 11,922]

Aura is like the best song in Gaga's entire discography

...and it's not even her song originally 

[Yoshi 35]

Well I'd probably take out JnD, Dope, MANiCURE, Swine and Fashion! from ARTPOP, but from BTW smdh ummm; Americano, Hair, The Queen, FOHL and Bad Kids. I really, really love the last two on born this way but if i were to shuffle the album they would be the ones i'd skip over