Jump to content
question

Why do some fans talk bad about Gaga's songwriting?


Monster2015

Featured Posts

Monster2015

You made a thread about a handful of people? Talk about overreacting.

well yea? What's wrong with that? 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Monster2015

The problem is not even saying the things they say (I myself think there's room for improvement)...the thing is they say these things about Gaga and then you look at their profile pics or at their comments and it's so contradictory...one thing is to say Gaga could improve and think of Joni Mitchell or Alanis Morisette as examples, but to say that and come up with (fill in the blank)? And I'm like...

15006090_02iHk.gif

 

Exactly what I meant! I probably should've rephrased it but yes

Link to post
Share on other sites

Supersonic

I don't understand the issue? Are we meant to be mindless zombies? No matter how many times I will probably be called a fake-fan I just don't want to slap honey on a young pancake.  :hunty:

If you don't wanna slap honey on a young pancake you are not art for michelangelo to carve who can't rewrite the agro of your furied heart. Bye.

Link to post
Share on other sites

SharGaga

Born This Way is ha best album as far as songwriting goes. ARTPOP's songwriting on the other hand has one of the worst lyrics possible imo. Songs like J&D and Donatella and MJH are trash lyrically. It's a shame songs like Princess Die didn't make the cut, while trash like J&D made it.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Miley

Well ARTPOP wasn't that great, I mean it's hard to relate/understand even as a fan. It's her right to express the way she wants, but how can something be genius if you don't get it as the audience 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Miley

Born This Way is ha best album as far as songwriting goes. ARTPOP's songwriting on the other hand has one of the worst lyrics possible imo. Songs like J&D and Donatella and MJH are trash lyrically. It's a shame songs like Princess Die didn't make the cut, while trash like J&D made it.

Wow I agree with this!!

Link to post
Share on other sites

lego

‘If they only knew how many bad songs I wrote before that good one.’

- Lady Gaga @ Songwriters Hall of Fame

FreePalestine
Link to post
Share on other sites

Benji

Because she's wrote some lyrically bad songs? I don't get the expectation in this fanbase to love every single thing Gaga does... she f*cks up, she's human, let it go.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Bette Davis

I love her song writing and although she has written a few cheesy lyrics (which are usually satirical e.g. Donnatella) , I think she's a lyrical genius.

 

People need to remember that this a FORUM and there is nothing wrong with people discussing, critiquing, making suggestions, expressing their opinions, positive or negative, as long as it is expressed in a RESPECTFUL manner.

 

People need to stop taking the opinions of others personally :saladga: When I see an opinion I disagree with I either debate my point or roll my eyes and move on. You all should try it :hunty:

Cold as ice cream, but still as sweet.
Link to post
Share on other sites

Nicole

This post is kinda a continuation from my first on a previous page - but being said that we are not obligated to love everything and we are entitled to expressing our opinions, there are ways to do so that isn't plain hurtful and unnecessary. Songwriting is a type of art - it is subjective and to straight out trash talk some lyrics - well, you can't get angry if someone else trash talks another aspect of Gaga's artistic expressions lol. There are ways to express opinions without acting as if other opinions are inferior or straight out being hateful, example follows:

"these song lyrics are so ****ty what the **** Gagaa sucks now and anyone who likes this is full of **** wow bye if she continues like this I'm unstanning"

vs

"in my opinion, Gaga's songwriting hasn't been at her best lately, hopefully she impresses me again in the future"

Link to post
Share on other sites

Riot Poof

Gaga has some questionable lyrics, but I'm a fan of the MUSIC. It's all good.

I'm not a woman. I'm not a man. I am something that you'll never understand.
Link to post
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

×
×
  • Create New...