Jump to content

Should Gaga top Katy's record?


Creyk

Featured Posts

Serendipity

​Commercial success doesn't necessarily depend on the quality of the song. Reminder that Harlem Shake went to #1. :emma:
Also by today's standards a #6 peak would be considered a flop :emma:
The things that matter the most are exposure (promo/hype whatever), a catchy hook, a pretty face and no negative backlash.

​Even Gangnam Style went #1 in many countries around the world and that was definitely not a good song

See talent here-->http://bit.ly/2eqeUxK
Link to post
Share on other sites

  • Replies 154
  • Created
  • Last Reply
Supersonic

​Even Gangnam Style went #1 in many countries around the world and that was definitely not a good song

​Just what I said. Quality does not equate success. :yes:

I mean Marry The Night, arguably the best song of Born This Way, peaked at #27. :emma:

Link to post
Share on other sites

SlaeUrAnus

​When are Gaga's songs radio friendly

When Just Dance and Pokerface were smashing there was literally RnB everywhere

​There are plenty of radio friendly Gaga songs. Just Dance and Poker Face were smashing because Gaga was the 'it' girl back then. Everyone wanted to listen to her :shrug:  

In my messy era.
Link to post
Share on other sites

Serendipity

​Just what I said. Quality does not equate success. :yes:

I mean Marry The Night, arguably the best song of Born This Way, peaked at #27. :emma:

​*#29

But I guess that's what happens when you post]pone it from

lead to second to third to fifth single

See talent here-->http://bit.ly/2eqeUxK
Link to post
Share on other sites

Creyk

​Lol you guys really underestimate her power just because she had an underperforming era that still did well :awkney:

​I think a lot of the underestimating doesn't happen because of the AP era, but because of her general attitude towards making music

Link to post
Share on other sites

Serendipity

​There are plenty of radio friendly Gaga songs. Just Dance and Poker Face were smashing because Gaga was the 'it' girl back then. Everyone wanted to listen to her :shrug:  

​This is it

Her music is supposed to change radio, not meant for radio

See talent here-->http://bit.ly/2eqeUxK
Link to post
Share on other sites

Creyk

​Just what I said. Quality does not equate success. :yes:

I mean Marry The Night, arguably the best song of Born This Way, peaked at #27. :emma:

​Excuse U, Scheiße is the best song from Born This Way and everybody knows that :laughga:

Link to post
Share on other sites

Supersonic

​Excuse U, Scheiße is the best song from Born This Way and everybody knows that :laughga:

​But now look at the commercial success of Scheiße :sis:

Link to post
Share on other sites

​Not when you get one

​Do you seriously think she's a D-lister who can't even chart a top ten anymore

ARTPOP could've snatched the 5#1s record if the promo was on spot and the era was done nicely

​no I do not seriously think that and I think it's as cheap as it is hard and isn't anywhere as great as it used to be and Gaga getting a number one sounds boring because her career has been more eventful than Katy's which goes like number one songs/ marriage/ break up song/ number one song/ number one song/ absence/ number one song/ dating someone/ a dark number one song/ superbowl non event/ absence/ getting herself pumped to shoot straight to the top of that great big chart. 

following her must feel like facebook every once in a while, so of course you need number ones to feel good about being a fan and then Gaga might seem to you like she also needs one to reclaim her place but truth is Gaga's got her own big fat place in the game and Katy doesn't which is why she needs to keep it up and Gaga doesn't.

there is no flamebait so don't try act incomprehensive. I am saying that Katy's career is less eventful than Gaga's (in my eyes) and that Gaga doesn't need to keep "smashing" because she's penetrated deeper into the music industry.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Serendipity

​But now look at the commercial success of Scheiße :sis:

​Ummm, It bubbled in the Billboard Bubbling Under Hot 10 while MTN entered at #98

See talent here-->http://bit.ly/2eqeUxK
Link to post
Share on other sites

Optimus

​Billboard called MANiCURE Pokerface 2.0

Venus could've pulled a BR

GUY had a magnificient video

some controversy and yes, she definitely would've gotten multiple #1s instead of a #4,#13 and a #76

​OMG at the delusion :lmao: Venus is the definition of  flop, MANiCURE too 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Creyk

​no I do not seriously think that and I think it's as cheap as it is hard and isn't anywhere as great as it used to be and Gaga getting a number one sounds boring because her career has been more eventful than Katy's which goes like number one songs/ marriage/ break up song/ number one song/ number one song/ absence/ number one song/ dating someone/ a dark number one song/ superbowl non event/ absence/ getting herself pumped to shoot straight to the top of that great big chart. 
following her must feel like facebook every once in a while, so of course you need number ones to feel good about being a fan and then Gaga might seem to you like she also needs one to reclaim her place but truth is Gaga's got her own big fat place in the game and Katy doesn't which is why she needs to keep it up and Gaga doesn't.

there is no flamebait so don't try act incomprehensive. I am saying that Katy's career is less eventful than Gaga's (in my eyes) and that Gaga doesn't need to keep "smashing" because she's penetrated deeper into the music industry.

​wouldn't the superbowl performance be something eventful though?

she slayed too

I mean yes left shark upstaged her but her I Kissed a Girl Performance>>>>>>>>>>>

Link to post
Share on other sites

Serendipity

​OMG at the delusion :lmao: Venus is the definition of  flop, MANiCURE too 

tumblr_inline_mgi7kyKejy1qaaiuu.gif

 

Venus was smash waiting

It had all the signs of BR

Gaga was crazy about it, you could tell

 

Me killing you for this blasphemy

tumblr_mu5zrklGFN1rkgii6o1_500.gif

 

See talent here-->http://bit.ly/2eqeUxK
Link to post
Share on other sites

Optimus

tumblr_inline_mgi7kyKejy1qaaiuu.gif

 

Venus was smash waiting

It had all the signs of BR

Gaga was crazy about it, you could tell

​BR>>>>>>>>>>. this trash

Venus would have been even a bigger flop than GUY

23w33i1.gif

Link to post
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


×
×
  • Create New...