Jump to content
opinion

They may have more commercial success but no impact


Quark

Featured Posts

Yanko

dark horse was kinda like dwuw

after dwuw we had hits like 

 

 

 

all of these songs sound like dwuw 

i dont think any you would argue with me over dwuw's influence een tho these kind of sound was around for forever 

dwuw just started the wave imo

same for dark horse just admit it :spin:  

Link to post
Share on other sites

  • Replies 259
  • Created
  • Last Reply
Quark

​the songs that i posted have the exact same structure as dark horse  im talking about structure not urban/trap sound 

 

But that is not impact. Since the main factor would have been that she had influenced mainstream trap music.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Yanko

Well if you are looking for songs that have the same exact structure as Dark Horse, you need not to look past hitting the next button on your Prism CD, where you will discover that all of Katy's music is the same damn song with different lyrics and a different souped up synth created by Dr. Luke or Max Martin. ;)

​i dont use prism :Chica: it's a ****ty album

most of her music is bubblegium and they sound the same 

but dark horse is nothing like other katy songs

waiitng for link :nails:

Link to post
Share on other sites

dark horse was kinda like dwuw

after dwuw we had hits like 

 

 

 

all of these songs sound like dwuw 

i dont think any you would argue with me over dwuw's influence een tho these kind of sound was around for forever 

dwuw just started the wave imo

same for dark horse just admit it :spin:  

:lmao: Wait I lied this is actually funny :lmao:

Link to post
Share on other sites

Yanko

But that is not impact. Since the main factor would have been that she had influenced mainstream trap music.

​:rip: dark horse had influence i already posted those songs that were hits because they share a similar structure which means dark horse had it's share of impact  :rip: 

that is impact when you influence something 

im tired. congrats on getting anther hit thread tho 

of course she didnt have the same  impact as gaga gaga basically started dance trend back in 2008 everyone was wearing random **** because she made it popular 

but you should give credits where it's due 

people will prbably come for me now

"why are you even here you dont like gaga balh blah blah"  whihc is so ****ing annoying since  she made me fall in love with music and ive been a fan since 2009 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Spyro

People who feel the need to derail threads need hobbies. (Not attacking Spyro) 

​I was attacking the people Enigma was attacking, not Enigma.

Spyro the Dragon
Link to post
Share on other sites

Fiona Apple

​if you want to make an impact it has to be successfull and everything you qioted had impact

lana opened door for more alternative direction and sia's voice is recognizable everywhere

edm music + unique vocals   

chandelier had huge influence it will be  remembered as one the best songs this decade

 

 

 

:lolly: 1)Yeah if you want to make an impact it has to be successful. But the fact that something is successful doesn't mean it had impact.. I don't think that Lana had a lot of impact.There were MANY mainstream alternative artists before her. 2)Most people (at least here) still think that Rihanna sings Chandelier so....

Link to post
Share on other sites

Spyro

People who feel the need to derail threads need hobbies. (Not attacking Spyro) 

​I was attacking the people Enigma was attacking, not Enigma.

Spyro the Dragon
Link to post
Share on other sites

Quark

​:rip: dark horse had influence i already posted those songs that were hits because they share a similar structure which means dark horse had it's share of impact  :rip: 

that is impact when you influence something 

im tired. congrats on getting anther hit thread tho 

DWUW and DH are just minor trends of an overal trendy sound. Gaga for example, actually influenced just about everyone to change mainstream music into electronic/dance sound regardless of the song structure. That is true impact.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Yanko

DWUW and DH are just minor trends of an overal trendy sound. Gaga for example, actually influenced just about everyone to change mainstream music into electronic/dance sound regardless of the song structure. That is true impact.

​oh so you have your own definitions of impact 

great 

guess there are no links then  :hunty:

Link to post
Share on other sites

Yanko

:lolly: 1)Yeah if you want to make an impact it has to be successful. But the fact that something is successful doesn't mean it had impact.. I don't think that Lana had a lot of impact.There were MANY mainstream alternative artists before her. 2)Most people (at least here) still think that Rihanna sings Chandelier so....

​thats because it reminds them of diamonds (which was written by sia(the impact) ) 

and i wanna see those many mainstream alternative artists (not 1 hit wonders like gotye) 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Fiona Apple

​thats because it reminds them of diamonds (which was written by sia(the impact) ) 

and i wanna see those many mainstream alternative artists (not 1 hit wonders like gotye) 

​Why not Gotye tho? Even him showed that it's possible to make an alternative hit. There have been a lot of them in the past. I got to go to school right now so I can't give you links. xD YOU said that Sia "had an impact because everyone knows her voice".. Now you change it lol... Anyway both obviously had an impact but it's that small that it's almost pointless.The music industry would be pretty much the same without them

Link to post
Share on other sites

Dorothy Gale

​thats because it reminds them of diamonds (which was written by sia(the impact) ) 

and i wanna see those many mainstream alternative artists (not 1 hit wonders like gotye) 

Just because Sia wrote songs for other people does not mean she had an impact. What about Bonnie McKees impact then? 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Quark

 

​oh so you have your own definitions of impact 

great 

guess there are no links then  :hunty:

There are no links because they are not necessary.

Link to post
Share on other sites

'All these other artists only have trendy hits or viral videos, buy they have little to no impact/influence. Also, is is quite obvious that no other artist right now has the overall talent and artistry that Gaga has. Gaga is still once in a lifetime kind of artist.'

sure enigma sure...

anyway you shouldn't really care about success or impact. just stan for the music and let the music speak for itself instead of numbers. really hate when this **** happens, because i just don't get why so many people are obsessed with success... gaga already has lots of $$$ and at this point she can flop forever and she'll still stay rich so success really doesn't matter anymore tbh

Link to post
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


×
×
  • Create New...