Could gaga pull off "My Immortal" or "Bring Me To Life" by Evanescence?

[Crystalline 993]

So, for LG5, we know Gaga said she might want to go a little more rock? Well I think personally she could pull off these two songs and slay if they were hers.
Do you?

 

 

Now if she did release these, where would they peak? Their sales? Video views, spotify streams? I want all your answers.

I honestly feel like she could SLAY "My Immortal" especially, because her voice could support it and she could come up with a perfect video (or pull off the original one), if these were hers.

Discuss!

[mariomania1234 11,368]

I would LOVE for her to do something along these lines. 

[Bad Bromance 5,809]

Totally!!!  I've been wanting Gaga to have an Evanescence type era.  I hope the next album is rock infused.  

[Gohan 16,548]

OMGGGGGG

STAN FOR THE QUEEN OF EMOTIONAL SONGS

She could easily sing Bring Me To Life, but My Immortal it's too hard

I can see her singing this one better though:

 

 

 

[Guest]

^^ expectations!!

 

reality: Judas 2.0 Venus 2.0 G.U.Y. 2.0 Bad Romance 3.0

[Paper Planes 340]

Probably. She would have to bring back the drunken/throaty whine from Dope for Evanescence, though.

[Jjang 2,262]

Yes.

 Evanescence's first 2 albums + unreleased tracks were brilliant. 

Gaga would be an amazing alternative rock artist. I'd stan so hard.

[HausofGabo 1,263]

I'd love to hear a "Call me when you're sober" cover  

[Crystalline 993]

So, for LG5, we know Gaga said she might want to go a little more rock? Well I think personally she could pull off these two songs and slay if they were hers.
Do you?

 

 

Now if she did release these, where would they peak? Their sales? Video views, spotify streams? I want all your answers.

I honestly feel like she could SLAY "My Immortal" especially, because her voice could support it and she could come up with a perfect video (or pull off the original one), if these were hers.

Discuss!

​Well I think like I mentioned in the OP, she could pull off "My Immortal" because it is a bit more poppy, but I think she could slay BMTL so much too. Also yes "Good Enough" is something she could also slay, maybe even "Call Me When You're Sober" or something. But like I said I'd also like to know where you guys think these would peak if she released them!

[Morphine Prince 107,600]

YES  

Imagine how amazing it would be  

I'M GOING UNDER

[Crystalline 993]

I mean IMO, I would melt inside if she released something similar to "My Immortal" next era, literally one of my top 5 favorite songs ever. I also think she should serve imagery in her videos kind of like that!

[Gohan 16,548]

YES  

Imagine how amazing it would be  

I'M GOING UNDER

DROWNING IN YOUUUUUUU

[Gohan 16,548]

I'd love to hear a "Call me when you're sober" cover  

La mejor canción de The Open Door, asdfghjklñ

[Morphine Prince 107,600]

I'd also love something like Tourniquet since it's a bit more basic and I think Gaga could pull it off like the real rock star she is: 

 

 

[Bad Bromance 5,809]

Yes.

 Evanescence's first 2 albums + unreleased tracks were brilliant. 

Gaga would be an amazing alternative rock artist. I'd stan so hard.

​Yes!!!  Gaga would totally be an amazing alternative rock artist.  I'd stan so hard too!!  

As you can see from my new avatar, I absolutely LOVE the alternative/grunge scene!!