Not a joke: In the industry/GP mindset, did katy perry replace lady G?

[Brown Eyes 0]

Another thing to keep in mind is that gaga has changed his voice and the way he sings since 2011

Very true. She had a very cool and appealing singing style back then. The perfect pop voice.

The way she sings on some ARTPOP songs actually detract from the songs (for example Dope, Gypsy, Fashion!, MANiCURE verses, Applause verses)

[MonsterOfSpain 8,278]

I'm coming to London for my Prismatic tour, are you gonna come?

 

*tumbleweed*

 

That was so funny 

[MelbHawker 6,583]

No. Katy will never gross the amount Gaga can touring, will never have the ability to write a #1 single without 6 additional writers, hasn't developed choreography, and follows her label blindly. 

This. All this is true.

But I really am not here for fanbases comparing artists (although it's inevitable and will always happen) and comparing their stats and extraneous factors away from their music such as writing/dancing etc. Katy's music is HUGE and brings joy to people. She's earned the following of millions of people by entertaining them. She's very different to Gaga. No-one's replaced anyone. They are both their authentic selves amidst the media/fanbase sh*tstorms.

[brizoda 3,211]

Very true. She had a very cool and appealing singing style back then. The perfect pop voice.

The way she sings on some ARTPOP songs actually detract from the songs (for example Dope, Gypsy, Fashion!, MANiCURE verses, Applause verses)

I prefer her actual voice (it has more raw emotion), but a lot of people don't think the same way (GP)

[GagaMyBlood95 9,808]

No she didn't REPLACE Gaga but Katy is much bigger now.

[MelbHawker 6,583]

katy is very close to be considered a chart legend..

 

she is the one with the CUTE OH MY GOSH outfits..

 

she is the one with the.. EPIC THEATRICAL PERFORMANCES..

 

[Pitch 204]

For her next era gaga NEEDS to reinvent herself she cant keep coming back with the same dance music with weird outfits, she needs a new style and new music, the GP are sick to death of her atm, look at Madonna who has lasted 30 years in the business and is still getting top tens, every time the GP got bored of her she came back with a new look and sound, it confuses the GP into thinking its something new when really its the same food just in a different packaging.

 

ARTPOP's great but honestly its nothing new and its missing something compared to her previous efforts, gaga needs to go out and find a new collaborator because DJWS + Gaga just dont create the magic that Redone + Gaga could, imo gaga should forget about ARTPOP act 2, release the safest songs to get the most out of the album and next year return with something COMPLETELY different, get the GP interested in her again.

[Psychedelic 1,098]

For her next era gaga NEEDS to reinvent herself she cant keep coming back with the same dance music with weird outfits, she needs a new style and new music, the GP are sick to death of her atm, look at Madonna who has lasted 30 years in the business and is still getting top tens, every time the GP got bored of her she came back with a new look and sound, it confuses the GP into thinking its something new when really its the same food just in a different packaging.

 

ARTPOP's great but honestly its nothing new and its missing something compared to her previous efforts, gaga needs to go out and find a new collaborator because DJWS + Gaga just dont create the magic that Redone + Gaga could, imo gaga should forget about ARTPOP act 2, release the safest songs to get the most out of the album and next year return with something COMPLETELY different, get the GP interested in her again.

THIS SO MUCH!!!

[Jester 6,273]

Did you just call Katy's performances EPIC and THEATRICAL

[Rollercoaster 2]

Katy currently is trying hard to be huge... it's falling flat partly because she has an awful voice.

comparison with Gaga is like comparing Kim Kardashian with Kate moss.