Jump to content

US Charts Discussion


Arturo

Featured Posts

  • Replies 34.8k
  • Created
  • Last Reply
Lion Heart

They're playing DWUW on HOT 99.5

 

Our impact :whitney:

▀▄▀▄▀▄▀▄▀▄▀▄▀▄▀▄▀▄▀▄▀▄▀▄▀
Link to post
Share on other sites

Arturo

It's nice to see DWUW Top 10 on Pop AT LEAST right now.

It should be official on Monday! :party:


-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

 

It's coming

 

49 -- BRUNO MARS Young Girls 656 -- 540 -- 6.313 -- 1 -- 49 656 540 6.313

Link to post
Share on other sites

VforVendetta

your poll doesn't prove anything tho :awkney: 90% Of Gaga's fans are not even active on GGD so ..

It is a statistical example though and can be considered accurate on some extend. It is more accurate than just a claim that fans don't think ARTPOP is that good anymore.
Link to post
Share on other sites

Lion Heart

It's nice to see DWUW Top 10 on Pop AT LEAST right now.

It should be official on Monday! :party:

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

 

It's coming

 

49 -- BRUNO MARS Young Girls 656 -- 540 -- 6.313 -- 1 -- 49 656 540 6.313

I thought he was done releasing singles from this album tbh

▀▄▀▄▀▄▀▄▀▄▀▄▀▄▀▄▀▄▀▄▀▄▀▄▀
Link to post
Share on other sites

Arturo

I thought he was done releasing singles from this album tbh

I'm glad he's not. If there's still single material left (I've been rooting for YG since before his 3rd single was announced), then why not go on? :)

Plus, YG has smash written all over it :giveup:

Link to post
Share on other sites

Desperado

I'm glad he's not. If there's still single material left (I've been rooting for YG since before his 3rd single was announced), then why not go on? :)

Plus, YG has smash written all over it :giveup:

i thought that song was a single before :toofunny: 

Link to post
Share on other sites

It is a statistical example though and can be considered accuratenon some extend. It more accurate that just a claim that fans don't think ARTPOP is that good anymore.

I didn't say fans, I said haters :rip:  I love every Gaga album .. and the metacritic scores are kinda accurate here is why:

The Fame don't deserve as much as Born This Way but you need to consider the timing - The Fame was Gaga's debut album and at the time the singles were really risky and interesting, while the album as a whole was retro style and the critics loved that. Then The Fame Monster was the modern and darkest side of The Fame .. and then Born This Way, Gaga took the game on another level ... And then ARTPOP is the same Dance music Gaga did with The Fame and TFM but It's just more EDM now and a bit more experimental ...  In my opinion Gaga's metacritic scores should be like that:

Born This Way - 80+ 

The Fame Monster - 78

ARTPOP - 72

The Fame - 72

Link to post
Share on other sites

VforVendetta

I didn't say fans, I said haters :rip: I love every Gaga album .. and the metacritic scores are kinda accurate here is why:

The Fame don't deserve as much as Born This Way but you need to consider the timing - The Fame was Gaga's debut album and at the time the singles were really risky and interesting, while the album as a whole was retro style and the critics loved that. Then The Fame Monster was the modern and darkest side of The Fame .. and then Born This Way, Gaga took the game on another level ... And then ARTPOP is the same Dance music Gaga did with The Fame and TFM but It's just more EDM now and a bit more experimental ... In my opinion Gaga's metacritic scores should be like that:

Born This Way - 80+

The Fame Monster - 78

ARTPOP - 72

The Fame - 72

Sorry, I didn't realise you said haters. As for metacritic scores I would put ARTPOP first and Ill explain why: BTW is the biggest step forward and change Gaga has done in her career so it would deserve to be highest. TFM is a solid POP EP and it contains one of the best Pop songs ever so it must also be high. TF was innovative a for the time it was released but it still remains commercial and full with fillers so it deserves something good but not near the others. Finally the truth is that ARTPOP isn't a big step forward from TFM and BTW but it contains most of the positives of all previous Gaga's works with some new elements. This makes it a very solid and complete record and so it deserves the top because an album that contains the amazingness of TF, TFM and BTW is perfect in my opinion. So my scores would be:

ARTPOP: 86

BTW: 84

TFM: 80

TF: 70-72

Link to post
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

×
×
  • Create New...