Jump to content

US Charts Discussion - TRACK 'DO WHAT U WANT' HERE!


Americano

Featured Posts

  • Replies 22.6k
  • Created
  • Last Reply
Americano

She also did this

 

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yqV2bWvqDAg

 

WE AREN'T READY GIRLS!!!!

 

:excited2: :excited2: :excited2:

 

i like that

Link to post
Share on other sites

Gov Hooka

This is the US Charts discussion, though.  Applause did extremely well and did what it needed to do.  It got the radio back on board with Gaga and healed a lot of the damage BTW did with casual listeners.  Her interviews are a lot more girly and relatable and the song itself is an ear worm.  

 

Yes, she didn't truly ditch her weirdness with the single.  I feel like her accent and lyrics during the verses and the way she screams the chorus held the song back.  But is this track not the perfect balance between mainstream and fan centered? It's obviously mainstream enough to stay in the top 10 for two months, but it's still something very Gaga that monsters love.  Of course you're complaining about how it didn't do as well as you'd like, but I doubt you would like the song if she decided to cater completely towards mainstream.

 

While on that subject, I would like to point out that Gaga only had one massively performing era: The Fame.  TFM actually wouldn't have been considered that successful had it been separate from The Fame.  Additionally, BTW is only feeding off of TF's status.  

 

So what I'm getting at is while you say that Applause is underwhelming considering it's Gaga, I would argue that you have over inflated expectations of Gaga.  Maybe The Fame was the exception in her career and her "normal" from now on will actually be a 2x platinum top 10 artist.  Considering the quality of the music she's producing as a top 10 artist, I don't see how that's a problem.  The performance of Applause is much more sustainable as far as a career is concerned, and is arguably what a "normal" lead single chart performance for Gaga actually should be.

I believe that I don't have inflated expectations for her though. I agree with you on the whole experimental cooky side vs. casual/relatable thing, however music is subjective and the only objective part of pop music we have is the charts. Considering Gaga's past career and everything, she has developed her own standard of success and I just want her to match that success. It's not like she let me down, Charts don't govern my life, it's just that I want to see her do really well as an extra perk. Lowering her to a new "normal" of 2x platinum is something that I think she can do better at, especially considering this is her first music after 2.25 years. Also, you are arguing that applause is the new normal based off of nothing except its own chart performance. However, my argument is actually based off of past sales, and in my eyes, Applause underperformed in comparison to the past sales, for lead singles. If this is what the new normal is, then unfortunately, this represents a Gaga in decline. I don't want Gaga to be in decline and for me to except her sales and be satisfied with them is representative of me accepting that she is in decline rather than wanting her to achieve a smash with Applause.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Americano

At least venus is GAGAS selection, not Interscopes. i feel like her choices are always 90000x better. she knows what a hit is, they dont, and its pisses me off.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Arturo

At least venus is GAGAS selection, not Interscopes. i feel like her choices are always 90000x better. she knows what a hit is, they dont, and its pisses me off.

Remember when we thought she chose Judas but then she revealed it was their choice?

Link to post
Share on other sites

She said she directed it correct? Therefore it's most likely almost done or done.. hopefully. That Ruth video is really cool too.

 

It gives me hope that Venus was the other choice (her choice) for the first single then.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Runway

She said she directed it correct? Therefore it's most likely almost done or done.. hopefully. That Ruth video is really cool too.

 

It gives me hope that Venus was the other choice (her choice) for the first single then.

being directed*

Link to post
Share on other sites

Scarlet Witch

She also did this

 

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yqV2bWvqDAg

 

WE AREN'T READY GIRLS!!!!

 

:excited2: :excited2: :excited2:

Sorry for the irrelevant comment but the model at the start looks like Ellen Degeneres. :toofloppy:

Link to post
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

×
×
  • Create New...