What if Lady Gaga was a gay man?

[Chromanne 2,696]

If Lady Gaga was a gay man, would he be still as popular as she is today? Imagine he has the same artistry, similar outfits and wigs, same discography from The Fame till Mayhem Requiem (maybe Free Woman is Free Human, I guess). A Star Is Born is a love story between two gay men. He is still engaged with Michael. Could he be still be that successful in 2008 without facing much homophobia? Would he still have a loyal fanbase since most of the queer people mostly have female pop stars as their favourites?

[NUTELLA 29,752]

1 minute ago, Chromanne said:

If Lady Gaga was a gay man, would he be still as popular as she is today? Could he be still be that successful in 2008 without facing much homophobia? Would he still have a loyal fanbase since most of the queer people mostly have female pop stars as their favourites?

No

[DrKindnessKunt2005 6,473]

I feel like Lord Gaga would have a massive cult following, but he wouldn’t be as mainstream as Lady Gaga. Maybe he could be slightly more successful than Adam Lambert. I just feel like society is too homophonic/prone to toxic masculinity to accept a “Lord Gaga”. 

ASIB would have been an indie film that Bradley Cooper would have made to be more “artsy”. 

[DESTROY UR DISEASE 21,214]

15 minutes ago, Chromanne said:

same discography

with songs like Scheiße, Aura, Shadow Of a Man?

[Ayesha Erotica 1,959]

10 minutes ago, Chromanne said:

 Would he still have a loyal fanbase since most of the queer people mostly have female pop stars as their favourites?

If s/he went to become a trans woman, maybe. Kim Petras also achieved fame. As a drag queen maybe, too. But if he stayed a man, probably not. 

Let's face it, when she appeared during the VMAs dressed as a man for the entire show, we were disappointed she wasn't a Queen with an extravaganze outfit. 

[DrKindnessKunt2005 6,473]

2 minutes ago, DESTROY UR DISEASE said:

with songs like Scheiße, Aura, Shadow Of a Man?

I could see the songs still working if the topics were changed from being feminist songs to songs about queer empowerment.

[Chromanne 2,696]

6 minutes ago, DESTROY UR DISEASE said:

with songs like Scheiße, Aura, Shadow Of a Man?

Yeah why not? A gay man can sing about women and their perspectives too, after all our lives kinda revolve on female pop stars. Gay men are more closer to women than other straight men. 

Aura and Shadow of A Man could be complicated, maybe Lord Gaga can include queer empowerment in it.

Edited 9 hours ago by Chromanne

[River 128,546]

4 minutes ago, DESTROY UR DISEASE said:

with songs like Scheiße, Aura, Shadow Of a Man?

"if you're a strong gay man, u don't need permission"

"I'm not a wondering straight, I'm a gay man of choice" "do u wanna see the man who lives behind the profile behind the grindr behind the kandura"

"riding on the shadow of another man, cheating when hot gays pass me by"

 

 

[gagacabana 8,414]

Your question is interesting but it overlaps gender/sexuality oddly. I think you should clarify if you mean "what if lady gaga transitioned?" X "what if lady gaga was a cis man?" 

Because if he was a transgender gay man (and, even more so, after having been known as a bi cis woman), society would freak out.

If he had been """born""" a man, then that's just like David Bowie and Freddie Mercury I guess

[DESTROY UR DISEASE 21,214]

32 minutes ago, DrKindnessKunt2005 said:

I could see the songs still working if the topics were changed from being feminist songs to songs about queer empowerment.

hmm, okay that makes sense, I see the vision 

[Controversiaga 17,013]

He would not be a mega star . He’d be an Adam lambert at best

[loveandpeace 2,015]

he probably would’ve been heavily compared to Prince

tbh we need a gay male force like that... something we’ve never seen before

Edited 7 hours ago by loveandpeace

[TheSine 6,974]

I'd be him number one fan probably if no on else is. I love Jo Caldrone.

[Kayioshka 3,500]

It would be Lord Gaga 

But how would his voice sounds like ?

[27monster27 16,035]

1 hour ago, Kayioshka said:

It would be Lord Gaga 

But how would his voice sounds like ?