Album you never want Gaga to release again

[TheARTPOPball 1,643]

I’m gonna go with chromatica. One album is enough for that sound, for her

everyone is saying Joanne but I think an album like Joanne without all the identity crisis would be just fine and I would enjoy it a lot

there were plenty of moments in the Joanne era where Gaga came out and I think it’s biggest artistic flaw is that she was looking for a way to be herself safely. She watered herself down but moments like the tour, Coachella, and the Super Bowl, Gaga was still there. She could have made that sound hers without abandoning all of What makes her, well Gaga. 
 

I also think the project in its spirits is still pretty close to how I view her as an artist. We see in the five foot two film that she is second guessing herself and is worried that fans are not going to like what she’s doing. But she has a vision, and she sticks to it anyways. And that to me, is very Lady Gaga. 

Edited 14 hours ago by TheARTPOPball

[thisboyisamonster 1,258]

I feel like she could do a Joanne 2.0 bit more pop rock and less country but much higher quality e.g. closer to ASIB, HMH, Glamorous Life, DWAS etc. and I would be here for that. 

[pachinko 10,753]

Joanne and Love For Sale do nothing for me. 
 

Chromatica did not age well. 
 

Cheek to Cheek is way superior than Love for Sale. They should not be grouped together . 

Edited 8 hours ago by pachinko

[RainOnGaga 872]

whoever says Chromatica should know there's a special place in hell for Chromatica haters

[IllusionLover 7,600]

On 7/29/2026 at 11:40 PM, BrandyFinest said:

Mayhem and chromatica are sister albums (negative(I love them both but neither are close to Gar's peak))

I always think of Chromatica as the door to MAYHEM, it's what drove her to find peace between her famous self and her human self.

[phantasmas 12,370]

everyone who voted Joanne will start coughing in 3 days

[Zombieboyyy 188]

I can't pick...

[DESTROY UR DISEASE 19,758]

On 7/30/2026 at 5:37 PM, PlastiscGuy said:

Joanne still remains Gaga's best album, haters

disagree but I'd never say a bad word about it

[Ladle Ghoulash 52,932]

37 minutes ago, IllusionLover said:

I always think of Chromatica as the door to MAYHEM, it's what drove her to find peace between her famous self and her human self.

Agreed. I think Chromatica and Harlequin were essential to Gaga creating MAYHEM.

[NUTELLA 26,726]

32 minutes ago, phantasmas said:

everyone who voted Joanne will start coughing in 3 days

Why make me wait? ☠️

[Sepsami 20,971]

You guys are wrong for picking Joanne cause you know damn well current Gaga would devour that, ARTPOP though, may she rest in peace. Love her to bits but that ship has sailed. 

[elegidadedios 4,861]

7 hours ago, thisboyisamonster said:

I feel like she could do a Joanne 2.0 bit more pop rock and less country but much higher quality e.g. closer to ASIB, HMH, Glamorous Life, DWAS etc. and I would be here for that. 

This will definitely happen at some point

[RichAssPiss 5,032]

Chromatica is her worst album, and even she knows it. 

She did nothing but talk about her own disappointment with it on the tour and since. MAYHEM's whole PR was literally like "Sorry bout that last one.:

[TheWineMonster 27]

I can't do this... one thing that I love about gaga is the fact that she's always experimenting and trying different things. In the past I would say harlequin, but I like it now. I think the fact that it was released before mayhem made the expectations too High for a POP album and I was disappointed, but now I like it for what it is. I would love if Chromatica had a sister album with more of a eurodance - 90s house vibe, like the demos of the album.

Edited 3 hours ago by TheWineMonster

[HotLikeMexico 6,562]

I’m so tired of the Joanne hate. I just got the pink vinyl for my birthday. I never hated the album but it’s been a while since I listened to it in full. I’ve however been listening to PI a lot recebtly and so I was excited for the day I got my record to relisten to the entire album. It’s honestly a great album, and it doesn’t deserve the hate it gets.