Better Pop Star: Dua Lipa vs Charli XCX

[LadyxGaGa 3,218]

also camera by charli is A BANGER !!!! i am so rdy for this album 

[Wet Fire 8,360]

Charli is the more interesting artist. Even early career songs like Boom Clap, Fancy and I Love It, though they became mainstream pop, are gems because of her singular delivery. 

[Gagaism 12,471]

I like Charli but Dula >>>>>>> I mean, better voice, better songs, better life, better husband 

[nATAH 56,777]

1 hour ago, Ladle Ghoulash said:

Ns, but I do not fck w/ Miz Snoozah Sleepah. Boilerplate, paint by numbers disco pop that could be released by anyone. Decent music, but basically leaves no impression on me

Physical was good and that's it, i said what i said

[Karl 3,572]

Dua lipa is NPC music for me so Charli, she has influenced other artists sounds and actually had an impact on the industry, and no I'm not talking about charts 

[LGAte 803]

I’m progressive so I’m not playing these games. 
 

But I have an idea for a poll:

 

Who is a better Gaga fan? 
-the one that puts artists up against eachother in meaningless online polls

-the one that takes Gaga’s advice and enjoys what they want to enjoy 

 

Vote!🗳️ 

[Head Empty 26,944]

5 minutes ago, LGAte said:

I’m progressive so I’m not playing these games. 
 

But I have an idea for a poll:

 

Who is a better Gaga fan? 
-the one that puts artists up against eachother in meaningless online polls

-the one that takes Gaga’s advice and enjoys what they want to enjoy 

 

Vote!🗳️ 

I understand the sentiment but there's no need to be haughty about it 

We're a bunch of bored/depressed/neurodivergent/sassy people on a pop forum. These polls aren't gladiator battles or feuds. Just casual conversation starters that most people are light-hearted and largely respectful about.

[ANVEEROY 65,206]

7 hours ago, LGAte said:

I’m progressive so I’m not playing these games. 
 

But I have an idea for a poll:

 

Who is a better Gaga fan? 
-the one that puts artists up against eachother in meaningless online polls

-the one that takes Gaga’s advice and enjoys what they want to enjoy 

 

Vote!🗳️ 

the one who feels like a saint in a pop forum. 

[EART HL I NG 1,230]

9 hours ago, LGAte said:

I’m progressive so I’m not playing these games. 
 

But I have an idea for a poll:

 

Who is a better Gaga fan? 
-the one that puts artists up against eachother in meaningless online polls

-the one that takes Gaga’s advice and enjoys what they want to enjoy 

 

Vote!🗳️ 

[princedeeblebleble 3,570]

Both are great in diffirent ways. Charli's music is a lot more fun, crazy and unique, also really gr8 lyrics at points, but at times I feel like it lacks a certain kind of polish in a way, and vocals aren't that great.  And I really don't enjoy her live preformances in a way, but then again as a lover of theatrics my opinion there is trash. 
On the other hand Dua is painfully safe, the songs are great but nothing too groundbreaking or revolutionary, and I wish she got more deep and personal with the lyrics (like what she did on Happy for you was so ****ing gorgeous!). But she is a faaaaaaaaaaaar better preformer and her vocals are divine, like when it comes to ROL I prefer the live orchestral live album. 
Overall they are both totally diff artists, I wish Charli took some vocal lessons and maybe cooked a song a bit more, and I wish for Dua to take a risk for a change :P But I do love them both! 

[BeyonkaAte 936]

21 hours ago, Ladle Ghoulash said:

Why do you always act like commercial success is the be all end all? By that metric, Taylor Swift is the greatest artist to ever live and McDonald’s is the greatest restaurant on Earth we all know that ain’t true lmao. Idgaf how it performed commercially, I form my own opinions based on my own preferences and evaluation of more objective criteria andI think FN is a fairly middle of the road nu disco/synth pop revival record. Wasn’t even the best record in that vein to come out *that year* (which would be Jessie Ware’s What’s Your Pleasure, which is a far more emotionally dynamic and compositionally interesting record with far better vocals).

Dua’s voice is *fine*, but imo Charli has more expressive range as a vocalist, whereas Dua’s delivery is generally emotionally flat and vacant. Have never once felt anything listening to a Dula Peep track.

clocking so good i had no choice but to like a post against the artist i voted for 

[weed 78,804]

Dua is absolutely the better pop star lol I don't have any hesitation, but I think in the same vein Charli is the better artist, no doubt about that. 

[Ziggy 13,992]

22 hours ago, Monstermilo said:

well then thats youre opinion and not everyone has the same opinion 

i personally feel like brat isnt a good album and charli cant really sing, FN was more consistent and dua has a more soulful, sultry voice thats more recongnizable 

if you dont wanna bring up objective stats then its just my subjective opinion versus yours 

I’ll give you soulful but I think charli’s voice is SO recognizable and even in her writing so much so when Selena Gomez bought that song from her last summer it was like well yeah ofc she did. I think both are equally recognizable 

[Ziggy 13,992]

1 hour ago, weed said:

Dua is absolutely the better pop star lol I don't have any hesitation, but I think in the same vein Charli is the better artist, no doubt about that. 

Yeah basically this summarizes my feelings, too. It’s clear Charli loves pop but is excited to push herself in any manner that inspires her even if it doesn’t land. Dua loves being the polished pop star making fun music everyone loves. Two very different artists in very diff niches

[weed 78,804]

1 hour ago, Ziggy said:

Yeah basically this summarizes my feelings, too. It’s clear Charli loves pop but is excited to push herself in any manner that inspires her even if it doesn’t land. Dua loves being the polished pop star making fun music everyone loves. Two very different artists in very diff niches

Exactly! I think it can be highlighted with like.. Dua got dragged for her dancing, she went into a studio and said mama play the track and teach me some moves. Whatever Charli gets dragged for I think she doubles down on, brat was a huge success and she said time for a new sound.