Controversial Gaga Takes (Music Editions)

[Ladle Ghoulash 49,314]

Apparently somewhat controversial as well: I love Gaga’s big theatrical vocals and I have basically no desire for her to scale it back lmao

[TheFrenchGuy 5,201]

40 minutes ago, Ladle Ghoulash said:

Apparently somewhat controversial as well: I love Gaga’s big theatrical vocals and I have basically no desire for her to scale it back lmao

Asking Gaga to scale back is like asking Katy Perry to release a good song

[LOVEDRUG 11,190]

Born This Way is, by quite some margin, her worst lead single.

[TheFrenchGuy 5,201]

My controversial take is that CSTH is not that great and I don't really care that she never performed it.

It's catchy but it's super generic lyrics and concept wise 

[Blackout19 15,346]

Chromatica is her best album 

Rain On Me & Free Woman are her best songs 

 

Bad Romance is overrated 

[Lady Gaga 2009 1,067]

While they're not her best or my favorites, the music videos for Million Reasons and The Dead Dance are cute and not the abominations this fanbase makes them out to be 

[GaGaAst 13,123]

ARTPOP-Joanne-Chromatica: Stains in Gaga's discography. These aren't good albums, by Gaga's standards. Her career slowed down a lot because of these run over 12 years (except ASIB in between). Streaming numbers prove it. I loved all three of these 3 albums when they came out, mostly because they were Gaga albums. But after listening to MAYHEM, I have finally accepted that these 3 albums were really bad for her standard.

TF-TFM-ASIB-JOKER-MAYHEM are in different tiers. 

 

[zevthepaparazzo 2,376]

TDD and SOAW are great songs

[Blackout19 15,346]

6 hours ago, PartySick said:

My only hot take is that Chromatica is bad but it seems enough people have come to see the light there that it's not controversial anymore

[Bronco 23,128]

4 hours ago, LOVEDRUG said:

Born This Way is, by quite some margin, her worst lead single.

Oh thank **** someone said it

[Bronco 23,128]

I don't care for Garden of Eden.

The ah-ah-ah bits are like listening to cats fighting in the garden at night. Truly grates on me. 

[Freud 5,864]

ARTPOP & Joanne are the most Un-Gaga albums production-wise. 

Mayhem proofed, that Gaga's distinct sound needs to be a combination of real live-instruments & synths. Both these album miss the one or another quality-wise, therefore for me her weakest projects sonically.

While ARTPOP misses any "soul" in the music/production, Joanne misses the "Pop/Synth" aspect

Edited 1 hour ago by Freud

[TimotheeChalamet 6,904]

Summerboy is awful

I Like It Rough is even worse 

Bad Kids is great, especially the verses

Y'all adored Chromatica when it came out 

[warhol killah 9,026]

The hype for ARTPOP in the fandom is overrated. It's not her best work, and some songs were just rehash of already produced instrumentals.

Chromatica is top 4 Gaga albums.

[Stylor 68]

Joanne is not only her worst album, but also one of the worst albums by any pop girl.

Edited 26 minutes ago by Stylor