Marry the Night Flopping VS. G.U.Y. Flopping

[Controversiaga 13,452]

Which flop was better? Marry the night flopping? Or GUY flopping? Who is the better flop?

[holy scheisse 22,692]

GUY bc floppage was normalized by then but MTN was the first flop (unless you count Judas) after her string of back to back hits 

[Hadrian 1,801]

better how sis 

Marry The Night was the better experience despite being a flop because the song and video are great, but I think a lot of monsters consider G.U.Y. flopping the death knell of ARTPOP, which is a slay of a flop in itself.

[ANVEEROY 64,368]

Why don't you get backlash for creating these threads? Discuss!

[OMF 3,595]

1 hour ago, Controversiaga said:

Which flop was better? Marry the night flopping? Or GUY flopping? Who is the better flop?

G.U.Y. Because it came after Venus MV and single got cancelled as well as Do What You Want. And Gaga poured a lot of her money into G.U.Y.

[MountainMonster 2,054]

Better we in quality? Better as in bigger flop? If you’re going to spam this place with yet another VS thread, at least elaborate. 
 

1 hour ago, ANVEEROY said:

Why don't you get backlash for creating these threads? Discuss!

homegirl does; she just doesn’t care. Plus she’s only responsible for 1/3 of them. The other two thirds are from a few other people. 

[Creyk 18,481]

I feel like guy was worse. Marry the night is just a genuinely bad song while guy is at least quality music.

[Sugar Baby 997]

GUY was worse cause it was the very last chance to save the era

meanwhile When MTN was released she was overexposed so it was expected but the era still had massive hits like born this way and the edge of glory 

[Ziggy 13,430]

Custom Giuseppe Zanotti 

[nATAH 54,995]

MTN had the better video so

[DESTROY UR DISEASE 17,740]

Marry The Night is a better song than G.U.Y.

Both have great videos but the one for MTN is way better

MTN was Gaga's first major flop especially when compared to other Born This Way singles, but despite that it feels like GP still cared about Gaga at that point. G.U.Y. though was a flop to the fullest and ARTPOP overall was a mess so I don't think anything could've saved it

 

therefore I'm choosing Marry The Night

Edited 6 hours ago by DESTROY UR DISEASE

[SleepingSun 946]

G.U.Y. was the flop to end all flops. An interdimensional fail felt across spacetime, solely responsible for Aliens not having contacted us yet, because of the immense second hand ambarrassment they felt.

[Ladle Ghoulash 44,060]

8 hours ago, ANVEEROY said:

Why don't you get backlash for creating these threads? Discuss!

Do you…seriously think they don’t get backlash for these? Lmao

[Ladle Ghoulash 44,060]

6 hours ago, Creyk said:

I feel like guy was worse. Marry the night is just a genuinely bad song while guy is at least quality music.

Imagine thinking a stale LoveGame reheat is better than one of her best songs…

[RainOnGaga 689]

imagine voting for which song flopped more