Better Dance Album: Renaissance vs Brat

[NemoMyName 1,839]

Another option?

[99people 34]

Superbloom by Jessie Ware 

[ANVEEROY 63,998]

15 minutes ago, NemoMyName said:

Another option?

Don't vote?

[gagacabana 3,370]

1 hour ago, Ladle Ghoulash said:

a top 3 Charli record

Which are 2 and 1?

[Horny Chicken 10,403]

Renaissance was a group project. Brat has Charli all over it. 

Have to give this to Brat. 

Edited 7 hours ago by Horny Chicken

[candydarling 1,977]

i always thought renaissence to be a bit overrated. brat anyday

[CatelynnMarie 4,438]

i am unsure if one can be better than the other. each project is it's own vibe and are both great dance albums. Brat feels like, young, grimy, and a bit unhinged whereas Renaissance feels matured, glamorous, and expensive.

i've listened to brat more as an album, but Renaissance i've had a handful of specific songs on repeat, i think a lot more than Brat. 

not really about the music itself, but Renaissance vinyl is one of the nicest quality that i own overall (package wise in particular) and was a great surprise that i appreciated. Brat's makes sense for what the album is, but i do prefer the Renaissance physical 

 

Brat might take precedence because of the cultural impact. Renaissance had a cultural impact as well, but Brat sticks out in my mind to me a bit more when it concerns pop culture. people are still using Brat aesthetic to promote their own content/ fave's music, granted, that is a year since release battle (2 years vs 4 years) 

Edited 9 hours ago by CatelynnMarie

[CAPRISONGS 1,650]

there's some fillers on renaissance that brat doesn't have so im going for brat

Edited 9 hours ago by CAPRISONGS

[PartySick 169,810]

I don't really care for Brat's sound.

House music isn't my favorite either but it beats out hyperpop any day  

[Blackout19 14,680]

[Wet Fire 8,166]

2 hours ago, Roughhouse Dandy said:

Hydrogen bomb vs. Coughing baby. Love Brat but Renaissance is in a different league entirely. 

Renny does NOT stand a chance on this website though 💀

It's not about this website, really. The general critical consensus also ranks Brat (metascore 95) higher than Renaissance (metascore 91). Both are superb albums. Let's not pretend one is a league apart than the other.

[Agunimon 519]

I voted brat. I was never really into Renaissance and find it has aged pretty quickly in comparison to brat.

[Duella Dvil 11,067]

(God this is such a flex)

Went to both tours and stanned both records but NOTHING touches Renny for me. One of the best records of all time and then the tours Jesus Christ the TOURS Renny absolutely devours Brat, idk how Ms Ecksiecks is winning because Renaissance is the blatantly superior record 

[Roughhouse Dandy 13,001]

17 minutes ago, Wet Fire said:

It's not about this website, really. The general critical consensus also ranks Brat (metascore 95) higher than Renaissance (metascore 91). Both are superb albums. Let's not pretend one is a league apart than the other.

The attitude towards Charli vs Beyoncé on here are very different and online scores mean nothing. We disagree ✨️

Both are great albums! Went to both tours and rock merch from both to this day. Hydrogen bomb vs. Coughing baby. 

[Ladle Ghoulash 40,810]

1 hour ago, gagacabana said:

Which are 2 and 1?

I’d say top three are: Brat, How I’m Feeling Now, and Pop 2