Gaga’s Most Cohesive Album … ?

[bxr 2,094]

5 hours ago, SleepingSun said:

It appears to me some of you may have failed to grasp the difference between cohesive and repetitive, as Chromatica is exactly that: Repetitive. If that's your definition of a cohesive album, may Jesus battle for your life. Babylon™ 

On a more serious note: Born This Way, at least to me, is Gagas most cohesive album sonically and thematically. And until Mayhem dropped, it was my favorite album of hers 

 

SleepingSun really said: WAKE. IT. UP.

 

Spoiler

 

Edit : The Glitter and Grease bow song manifestation … have fun, be yourselves, and stay shiny club kids

Edited April 4 by bxr

[KindnessPunk 2,477]

4 hours ago, Anderson123 said:

Chromatica is probably the most cohesive, followed by Mayhem and The Fame Monster. 

 

4 hours ago, TimotheeChalamet said:

Chromatica 

 

4 hours ago, Lucas said:

100% Chromatica, then The Fame.

 

4 hours ago, PartySick said:

Chromatica because

 

4 hours ago, Economy said:

Id say Born This Way, Chromatica and Joanne. Maybe The Fame as well

 

ARTPOP and Mayhem definitely feel more random to me

 

 

4 hours ago, monketsharona said: Chromatica, like any day

Chromatica, like any day

Chromatica FINALLY getting its flowers!!! THANK YOU GGD !!! CHROMATICA FOREVERRRRR @Blackout19 WE WONNNNNNNNN

[Purrrrrr 18,018]

define cohesive 

[Purrrrrr 18,018]

I feel like BTW is because the album cohesively fits the mission statement  but then there's also Government Hooker and electric chapel on the same album but it also makes sense 

[TEANUS 16,140]

In order of cohesion to sonic chaos

1. Joanne

2. Chromatica

3. The Fame

4. Born This Way

5. The Fame Monster

6. ARTPOP

7. MAYHEM

[Controversiaga 15,963]

The fame and Chromatica 

[bxr 2,094]

2 hours ago, Zombiecat said:

define cohesive 

cohesive (adj.)

co·he·sive kō-ˈhē-siv  

: exhibiting or producing cohesion or coherence 

Spoiler

cohesion (n.)

co·he·sion kō-ˈhē-zhən 

1: the act or state of sticking together tightly

especially : unity

2: union between similar plant parts or organs

3: molecular attraction by which the particles of a body are united throughout the mass

 

coherence (n.)

co·her·ence kō-ˈhir-ən(t)s 

1: the quality or state of cohering: such as

a: systematic or logical connection or consistency

The essay as a whole lacks coherence.

b: integration of diverse elements, relationships, or values

 

Jesting aside though, when they’re side by side, “Cohesion” feels like Chromatica cohesive (plants, organs, and molecular attraction echo the Chromazone), but “Coherence” as the integration of diverse elements echoes Chroma’s opposition … intriguing (or as intriguing as definition dives can be in context) 

2 hours ago, Zombiecat said:

I feel like BTW is because the album cohesively fits the mission statement  but then there's also Government Hooker and electric chapel on the same album but it also makes sense 

I feel like GH, Scheiße, Americano, and Judas are at the Electric Chapel every Sunday … Black Jesus presides, and Bloody Mary teaches Sunday School for the Bad Kids

[bxr 2,094]

1 hour ago, TEANUS said:

In order of cohesion to sonic chaos

1. Joanne

2. Chromatica

3. The Fame

4. Born This Way

5. The Fame Monster

6. ARTPOP

7. MAYHEM

I appreciate that this list is deceptively chaotic in its own right … and “cohesion to sonic chaos:” new music barometer unlocked

[bxr 2,094]

54 minutes ago, Controversiaga said:

The fame and Chromatica 

… and this is The Fame  (unironically feeling The Fame’s cohesiveness was starting to get a bit “I’ll be lonely, too”)

[LUST FOR GAGA 95]

chromatica. mayhem is her least cohesive 

[Blackout19 15,646]

chromatica, of course

[Blackout19 15,646]

6 hours ago, KindnessPunk said:

 

 

 

 

 

Chromatica FINALLY getting its flowers!!! THANK YOU GGD !!! CHROMATICA FOREVERRRRR @Blackout19 WE WONNNNNNNNN

[Blackout19 15,646]

finally, everybody sees the light 

[PartySick 172,344]

7 hours ago, KindnessPunk said:

 

 

 

 

 

Chromatica FINALLY getting its flowers!!! THANK YOU GGD !!! CHROMATICA FOREVERRRRR @Blackout19 WE WONNNNNNNNN

Sure

"Flowers"

[River 127,150]

It’s funny how Chromatica is the most cohesive album but this cohesiveness is it’s negative point