gumzy3000 7,551 Posted October 20, 2025 Share Posted October 20, 2025 39 minutes ago, PartySick said: Oop 1-for-1 my answers. Would have accepted Electric Chapel in place of Teeth or LoveDrug though. Overrated: Dance in the Dark (good but not even the best non-single from TFM) Venus (there's a reason DWUW took off before it did) Alice (one of her worst songs) Wait, your right, Electric Chapel is severely underrated too! Your overrated list though... trolly troll troll Quote Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
TAIPEI 2,851 Posted October 20, 2025 Share Posted October 20, 2025 (edited) underrated: monster / black jesus † amen fashion / venus overrated: applause / shallow / die with a smile Edited October 21, 2025 by TAIPEI Quote Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
PartySick 164,701 Posted October 20, 2025 Share Posted October 20, 2025 44 minutes ago, Blackout19 said: i feel bad for you I will die on the hill of Alice being 30% of a song Flat production, weak sound, boring percussion (that plagues the whole album though), weak lyrics, two lines in the only verse, the only redeeming thing about it is that bridge and those 20 seconds don't make up for the opening track of her weakest album being such a let down. Even the live production, something that saves every other Chromatica track, couldn't lift Alice out of her mediocre (by Gaga's standards) hole I chose VIOLENCE 🥀 1 Quote Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
AVeryGagaHolyDick 27,915 Posted October 20, 2025 Share Posted October 20, 2025 Overrated: - Rain On Me - Happy Mistake - Perfect Illusion Underrated: - Eh, Eh - Don't Call Tonight - Folie À Deux Quote Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Agunimon 268 Posted October 20, 2025 Share Posted October 20, 2025 Underrated: Fashion!, Enigma, So Happy I Could Die Overrated: Happy Mistake, Bad Romance, Telephone ---- I guess I'm not really sure. I'm not super into these songs compared to others so that's why I'm picking them. Quote Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
elsamars 4,709 Posted October 20, 2025 Share Posted October 20, 2025 (edited) Underrated: Electric Chapel, Mary Jane Holland, Goverment Hooker Overrated: Abracadabra, Shallow, GUY, DWAS, 911, Rain on Me Edited October 20, 2025 by elsamars benson boone can f*** me all day long Quote Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
uglysexy 186 Posted October 20, 2025 Share Posted October 20, 2025 Underrated: Highway Unicorn Perfect Illusion Sine from Above Overrated: The Edge of Glory Million Reasons Applause Quote Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
BELLYACHE 1,457 Posted October 20, 2025 Share Posted October 20, 2025 (edited) Overrated aka songs that yall like but I don’t think it’s all that: Poker Face (overplayed to the max and repetitive, godly visuals tho) Summerboy (it’s cute but a skip if I’m listening to the entire album, a bop if I’m outdoors) Born This Way (overplayed and I forgot this song exists sometimes) Applause (same thing as BTW, verses are ugly asf) Do What You Want (idk something feels missing) ARTPOP (yall love this song but besides the amazing lyrics i don’t see anything special about it other than a filler album song) Enigma- (cheesy asf) Sine- (corny song corny beat, story is decent) Stupid Love (jk Ik yall hate it, deserved) Vanish Into You (feels scattered and flat for me, if it had a more mellow haunting production then yes but it’s washed) How Bad Do You Want Me (um, what is this) underrated LOVEGAME (her best song ) Money Honey Starstruck I like it Rough Disco Heaven Electric Chapel Black Jesus AURA Sex Dreams Mary Jane Holland!! Jewels and Drugs (without the last rap verse the song is a bopp and def better than a lot of mid songs in her catalogue) Donatella Diamond Heart John Wayne DANCIN IN CIRCLES (SO MUCH FLAVOR) Perfect Illusion Hey Girl (such a vybeee) Angel Down ALICE Shadow of A Man GARDEN OF EDEN (whatttt!!!! Can’t believe this wasn’t a single 💀) KILL FOR LOVE Edited October 20, 2025 by BELLYACHE Quote Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
HeavyCapiLover 4,189 Posted October 20, 2025 Share Posted October 20, 2025 Underated : Lovedrug (!!!), Manicure, Black Jesus Overrated : Summerboy, Disease, Rain on Me Quote Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
lilmonster2424 1,761 Posted October 20, 2025 Share Posted October 20, 2025 Underrated: Black Jesus Amen Fashion, Fashion of his Love, Jewels N' Drugs (yes I said it, I love this song and it gets sooo much hate), Killah Overrated: 911 (by the fans), Shadow of a man (its a great song but I don't understand how it has more streams than Perfect Celebrity, Zombieboy and Killah which are MUCH better imo) Just have to point out I love how Perfect Illusion has been on both overrated and underrated lists, shows how subjective this is. Quote Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
27monster27 14,601 Posted October 20, 2025 Share Posted October 20, 2025 Underrated: Hey Girl Donatella Money Honey Overrated: MANiCURE (iTunes Festival version) Government Hooker Boys Boys Boys I don't inherently dislike any of her songs, but some of them do it less for me than others. he/him/his Quote Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
qoqo 4,024 Posted October 20, 2025 Share Posted October 20, 2025 Nothing is overrated because if people love something who am I to say otherwise but I think Enigma, Boys Boys Boys, Perfect Illusion, G.U.Y., Sexxx Dreams, Bad Kids and Fashion Of His Love are all incredible songs often overlooked either by fans or the GP Quote Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
LUST FOR GAGA 39 Posted October 20, 2025 Share Posted October 20, 2025 Underrated: Disease Zombieboy Sexxx Dreams Overrated: Replay Edge of Glory LoveGame Quote Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
HeAteMyh3art 2,262 Posted October 20, 2025 Share Posted October 20, 2025 I relistened to Joanne and... I actually almost cried. I'm sorry for doubting you @PartySick Underrated: - Hey Girl - I genuinely used to think this sounded like 💩 - Grigio Girls - Come to Mama mandatory mention: The Beast Overrated: - Starstruck - this is not an Electric Chapel yall - Summerboy - SORRY NOT SORRY I didn't care when she played it night 1 - Edge of Glory is still the worst song on Born This Way you're now blinking and breathing manually 1 Quote Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
PartySick 164,701 Posted October 20, 2025 Share Posted October 20, 2025 17 minutes ago, HeAteMyh3art said: I relistened to Joanne and... I actually almost cried. I'm sorry for doubting you @PartySick Underrated: - Hey Girl - I genuinely used to think this sounded like 💩 - Grigio Girls - Come to Mama Exactly yes, thank you 🥀 Quote Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Featured Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.