Are we too harsh on Taylor Swift?

[nath4gaga2 266]

No. End of discussion.

[Cavadour 2,556]

Maybe this will be the one variant too many...

[LauraPalmer 1,772]

no. 

everything i say about her comes from the perspective of a former fan - i own most of her old CDs and i’ve seen her in concert. but there has been such an undeniable decline in quality since lover.

to watch her put out two incredibly mediocre pieces of work over the past couple years (ttpd + showgirl) while so many women in the industry have been absolutely killing it lately and have put out such creative projects - Gaga, Charli, Lorde, Chappell, Beyonce, Ariana, Doja, Billie, Olivia, and that’s just to name a few - is so disheartening because she will come out on top without trying every single time. 

[Cavadour 2,556]

She sure knows how to run a business...

Spoiler

Taylor Swift Gave a Whopping $197 Million in Bonuses to Eras Tour Performers, Crew on Top of Their Salaries

 

[gagafan1394 285]

absolutely not

in fact we should be should be harsher

[TheMontebello 684]

We're not harsh enough

[Joshie 757]

Erm

I would pretty much let Taylor know that she is a boring **** and, um the album that she gave me was
not something that I would particularly listen to myself.

They were old maiden type of variants, and she said that those variants were meant to be eaten up EVERYONE and their grandmas.

So if that is the case she should have put them back in the studio and she should never even recorded them because she
was UNQUALIFIED to give me that album if that's the case

and, um I think that Taylor is just a
disgrace. She's a disgrace to women who are actually talented and classy and, um she just doesn't have the vernacular she
thinks she possesses

Somebody lied to her several times and
told her that she was a showgirl, a poet, hot and sexy
and beautiful and she's nothing like that
She's nothing of the sort

 

Edited October 6, 2025 by Joshie

[Taylucifer 5,207]

yes.

[HotLikeMexico 5,556]

No. 

[Flippy 13,357]

Absolutely. Seems like a lot of people here need to read the guidelines on flamebait again

[Rahrahbitchson 21,691]

[TheARTPOPball 963]

5 hours ago, LOVEDRUG said:

For everyone here who claims to hate her, it's remarkable about how much you all talk about her. It's one thing to discuss her new album or criticise her for things that she's done that you dislike, but the sheer quantity of threads is just bizarre. There are users in this thread who I see talking about her more than they talk about Gaga, on a Gaga forum.

The evidence being that out of nine threads in the 'new threads' category, five are about Taylor Swift. It's just unhinged.

I mean this IS a gaga forum but taylor swift is a big part of pop culture and is in our faces 24/7. I don’t think it’s unbelievable that people are discussing her on a pop culture forum… nobody had any problems taking their turns throwing stones at Katy Perry. Why is the line drawn at Taylor Swift? 

[Pablo 8,088]

Too harsh? Maybe, I try not to think about her 

Edited October 7, 2025 by Pablo

[salty like sodium 2,138]

6 hours ago, princedeeblebleble said:

We're not harsh enough, especially the critics  like Karma was great as well as Florida, but everything else has been so mid since Folklore/Evermore. 

i'd be so much more inclined to agree with you if you hadn't quoted two of her worst songs from the last two album cycles 

[BillieGOAT 5,266]

I don’t think so. She’s literally a billionaire.

She’s practically squeezing every last penny out of her most devoted fans for “exclusive content” laced into all these different variants. The least she can do is write music worth what she’s charging for it.