Metacritic Debut: The Life of Showgirl - 73

[elsamars 3,171]

49 minutes ago, Just A Holy Fool said:

lol the fact that a 69 MC score is considered a total flop for Taylor, but it kind of is. 

Actually recently reviews are so inflated, with these scores it sits at

#233 out of 244 albums in 2025(MC)

#515 out of 531 albums in 2025(AOTY)

[Nagini 3,191]

23 hours ago, elsamars said:

Metacritic is working hard with weights to keep it higher. 
 

15 reviews are below 68, only 5 are above.

Literally this... it should be in the low 60s but it's at 70 right now because of 5 publications? Makes no sense. She's legit like Trump, forcing everybody to live in an alternate reality where the truth is concealed and dissent is silenced. Her & her album are still a piece of ****.

[HBDYWM Stan 750]

19 hours ago, Nagini said:

Literally this... it should be in the low 60s but it's at 70 right now because of 5 publications? Makes no sense. She's legit like Trump, forcing everybody to live in an alternate reality where the truth is concealed and dissent is silenced. Her & her album are still a piece of ****.

I am here to rant too so let me piggy back Lol. These reviews and she's going to break Adele's record is so annoying. She truly pulled out every trick to get this insane week. Hopefully, we get to watch it plummet because GP wasn't truly interested/enjoying her. Adele went on to sell 17M worldwide  in 42 days. She also had a song spend ten weeks at number 1. Ok Taylor, now show us it's all hype and that's it. I might need therapy for how much I've been sick of her/(her fans/team] lately 

[popkulture 326]

She paid for the positive reviews. This album is a new low for her and was a massive disappointment. She's been going downhill ever since her "All American" PR relationship to the football idiot.