Which One Should Gaga Pursue As Next Singles?

[RAMROD 106,911]

These two sings are the only two non singles songs, (for now), from MAYHEM on her Top 10 Spotify list. Should she catch the momentum and make this, or even both - double a side, into new singles soon?? Clearly the locals and some of us fans are loving these songs.
 

 

 

[Siena 6,158]

Garden of Eden and Zombieboy are the best options imo. Also we NEED a video for garden of eden, I keep imagining some sick visuals with lots of snakes and I need to see it come true lmao 

Edited yesterday at 04:23 PM by Siena

[REALITY 74,817]

Garden of Eden is the more interesting choice, but can I be honest......HBDUWM is probably my most streamed song from MAYHEM  It's just so easy to listen to and I can have it on repeat for hours  I wouldn't mind if she picked that as the next single—though I doubt she will.

[Nycboy 1,040]

Hear me out: next singles need to be Vanish into You and HBDUWM. 

Garden of Eden is one of my faves on the album by a long shot. But it’s a fun campy dance song. And Gaga already served that vibe with Abracadabra, which didn’t perform too well on the BBH100. I have a feeling GOE would flop with the GP. The core audience for this song are the gays and we are already streaming it. 

Vanish Into You on the other hand could actually become a hit if she released it as a single. It wasn’t my favorite song at first, and even though I prefer GOE and Abracadabra, I honestly cannot stop playing Vanish Into You over all the other songs. It’s glorious, addictive, very easy to listen to and her vocals are insane. The GP and radio would eat it up. It’s almost like a classic Gaga power ballad like Shallow/DWAS but a bit more upbeat. It showcases a totally different side to Mayhem compared to the earlier singles. I also think this is her best contender for a Grammy for best pop solo performance.  

Now, HBDUWM is obviously just another hit waiting to happen. Why not capitalize on that?? 

[NemoMyName 248]

I still don't get why Interscope haven't promote abracadabra with extra remixes like they usually do for singles, we are in some kind of joanne single promotion territory for absolutely no reason at all

[SpadesToStart 3,146]

I’d rather have no 3rd single than HBDUWM. 
There, I said it, and I’m not sorry about it.

[nodandsmile 10,029]

I think it's kinda premature to declare either of these two as single worthy, it's not like they are pulling a BOAF! Although I think it's important to note that this is pretty normal for Garden since it got playlisting, HBDUWM on the other hand got nothing so it' more impressive! 

That being said, I don't think they'll be anymore singles since we already got three... unless something blows up on its own, or remix, or new song from Deluxe!

 The last three cases are only way an era can be extended in the streaming era imo

[PinkJelly 1,748]

  On 3/25/2025 at 6:00 PM, NemoMyName said:

I still don't get why Interscope haven't promote abracadabra with extra remixes like they usually do for singles, we are in some kind of joanne single promotion territory for absolutely no reason at all

Expand  

This!
 

Kind of hoping for a remix album, we got ‘The Remix’ for The Fame, Born This Way (The Remix), Dawn of Chromatica too - still makes no sense, the Chromatica singles got DJ mixes why doesn’t Mayhem 🥲 

As for next single, I’d be happy with VIY, HBDYWM or Perfect Celeb, the latter being my personal fave off Mayhem.

[JustTea 5,050]

Straight males are eating GOE, Taylor fans are eating HBDUWM, VIY is probably for older audience and has wider approach 

[ItalianGuy 6]

  On 3/25/2025 at 4:58 PM, Nycboy said:

Hear me out: next singles need to be Vanish into You and HBDUWM. 

Garden of Eden is one of my faves on the album by a long shot. But it’s a fun campy dance song. And Gaga already served that vibe with Abracadabra, which didn’t perform too well on the BBH100. I have a feeling GOE would flop with the GP. The core audience for this song are the gays and we are already streaming it. 

Vanish Into You on the other hand could actually become a hit if she released it as a single. It wasn’t my favorite song at first, and even though I prefer GOE and Abracadabra, I honestly cannot stop playing Vanish Into You over all the other songs. It’s glorious, addictive, very easy to listen to and her vocals are insane. The GP and radio would eat it up. It’s almost like a classic Gaga power ballad like Shallow/DWAS but a bit more upbeat. It showcases a totally different side to Mayhem compared to the earlier singles. I also think this is her best contender for a Grammy for best pop solo performance.  

Now, HBDUWM is obviously just another hit waiting to happen. Why not capitalize on that?? 

Expand  

Agreed 100 percent she needs a long run hit(s) and to show a different side to the album. 

[Bronco 8,124]

HBDUWM is the one to chase if she wants a GP hit.

Garden of Eden is the one to chase if she wants a moderate hit the gays love like Abracadabra

[Railing 2,717]

I vote for the secret third option (Vanish Into You) 

[Murakami27 3,455]

All I care is that we see Mistress Mayhem in the MV again. 

[elegidadedios 1,144]

  On 3/25/2025 at 6:50 PM, JustTea said:

Straight males are eating GOE, Taylor fans are eating HBDUWM, VIY is probably for older audience and has wider approach 

Expand  

This. No need for HBDUWM and GOE to be a single, they can get "huge" on their own way because of those audiences... VIY is the best choice (even tho my ass wishes for a Killah MV lmao)

[MountainMonster 176]

Y’all want the music not the bling. Then you want both. Based on Apple Music, iTunes and Spotify collectively, GoE is numerically the choice followed by HBDUWM then Vanish (and don’t hit me with the play listing, so did Vanish and it’s completely MIA, plus we saw playlisting didn’t ultimately help Disease or Abra). If you want art, any of them, probably Killah because it’s clearly her favorite.