Why are Gaga fans allergic to her disco/funk inspired tracks?

[princedeeblebleble 1,044]

Lack of taste, next question

[Willeo Soeurs 18]

I guess they were hoping for the whole album to sound like Abra or Disease 

That being said, its their loss. Ask them to wait another 4-5 years and try to hate again. 

[chun li 2,835]

Oh i’m VIBIIIING to those songs so much I'm having the best time

But I do think the album title/aesthetics/booklet/promotion was HEAVILY misleading and doesn’t fit the vibe of the actual music AT ALL 

so if anybody was expecting dark goth emo music i get them because gaga girl... u did them dirty

[misha4ever 1,260]

Eh?

I only read a few people here, including me, who are not fond of 70s-80s sounds, but at least for me, I'm still processing the album. I see most people, fans and gp, loving it.

[Addison Rae 15,596]

it’s funny bc killah was so instant for me

[DISZKO 741]

I am personally a huge fan of disco (username duh) love all her pre fame tracks that are funk and disco inspired. Retro dance freak, disco heaven are such bops. I was very very happy when I heard these tracks. I love the raw funky vibes woth her growling and playing with her tone. I could totally see her explore the type of music like Killah
 

This Era i told myself im not gonna have expectations and from previous experience i expected that the album might sound totally different to what I would think it is. Pleasently surprised, cant complain! I would hope for the extra songs to be on streaming platforms but they are exclusive so no chance i think. 

[DISZKO 741]

18 minutes ago, chun li said:

Oh i’m VIBIIIING to those songs so much I'm having the best time

But I do think the album title/aesthetics/booklet/promotion was HEAVILY misleading and doesn’t fit the vibe of the actual music AT ALL 

so if anybody was expecting dark goth emo music i get them because gaga girl... u did them dirty

I dont think its misleading, i dont understand. I mean yes its not what people generally think of disco or funk but creative freedom allows to play with aesthetics, there have been many subgenres of disco, synth and electronic music. Loads of experimental french, italian producers created obscure albums with dark imagery when it was disco. 
 

check out Black Devil Disco Club for example. His whole album is dark electronic funk singing about the devil and bad acid trips.

 

also we are just getting into the era, we dont know what Gaga will bring to us visually for the singles. Im sure it will make sense.

Edited 22 hours ago by DISZKO

[Red 96,996]

Apparently I’m not a fan?

[DISZKO 741]

50 minutes ago, Willeo Soeurs said:

I guess they were hoping for the whole album to sound like Abra or Disease 

That being said, its their loss. Ask them to wait another 4-5 years and try to hate again. 

I have a friend whose reasoning was exactly this. But I think you can find elements of those songs expressed in other tracks. 

[Decodekid 27,708]

My comment would get me a WP, anyway go stream 

 

[LeafBug 8,091]

[Creyk 17,492]

IDK I saw a lot of praise for dont call tonight and zombie

[RebeldeFaith 4,883]

Too many of them grew up only listening to blender music. 

[MadArchitect 742]

1 hour ago, DISZKO said:

I dont think its misleading, i dont understand. I mean yes its not what people generally think of disco or funk but creative freedom allows to play with aesthetics, there have been many subgenres of disco, synth and electronic music. Loads of experimental french, italian producers created obscure albums with dark imagery when it was disco. 
 

check out Black Devil Disco Club for example. His whole album is dark electronic funk singing about the devil and bad acid trips.

 

also we are just getting into the era, we dont know what Gaga will bring to us visually for the singles. Im sure it will make sense.

I mean, there was also her saying that what suprised her the most was how hard the beats were, but the harder beats on the album are Disease and Abracadabra, also her describing the album as a series of gothic dreams, and altho thematically it kind of fits that description, the sound of it is way less darker than what anyone would think a Gothic dream sounds like...
Also her remarking how the songs on the album were exercises on chaos also made me picture a harder and darker sound, i don't even think this is the more chaotic album she has, i think BTW and ARTPOP are more chaotic and would fir better that description
 

I know that she said to expect the unexpected and that with with the firsts two songs you'd know what kind of album you're about to listen  but then you don't, however with the picture she was painting previously i think that is understandable how anyone would've thought that unexpectancy would go in a different direction

I think she shouldve maybe allude more to the retro, disco and funk vibes of the album which was what most of the songs ended up being like, which was a total surprise, and maybe that's what she wanted, but it was pleasant to some people and kinda disapointing for others

[Mr Oak 7,539]

5 minutes ago, MadArchitect said:

I think she shouldve maybe allude more to the retro, disco and funk vibes of the album which was what most of the songs ended up being like, which was a total surprise, and maybe that's what she wanted, but it was pleasant to some people and kinda disapointing for others

She literally said word for word that the second half of the album would be funky