Gaga: 'Garden of Eden' Snippet

[Dramatica 13,578]

5 minutes ago, Nyctophilus said:

Nope, it was not my intention to 'eat' anything. I was just expressing my opinion, which is apparently only allowed on these forums if you agree with everything everyone else thinks. Otherwise, you get comments telling you to 'stfu' or 'take a Xanax'. The toxicity of this community is honestly unreal.

There is no intention of being toxic, and I'm sorry if you felt that way.

But it's a thing to say: in my opinion the snippet doesn't sound catchy to me.

A whole other thing to say: this sounds like AI, the lyrics are terribly uncreative.

 

If you are commenting to share how negative you feel about something, why not give it a chance until it's released at least? Or better, no need to spread negativity in here

[Kayi 2,074]

Private Audition + Reloaded + Out of Control 

This one is for the LMs who know her unreleased songs 

[Hydrangea 6,104]

me on the adrena lawn

[Starmie25 16,203]

22 minutes ago, Nyctophilus said:

Nope, it was not my intention to 'eat' anything. I was just expressing my opinion, which is apparently only allowed on these forums if you agree with everything everyone else thinks. Otherwise, you get comments telling you to 'stfu' or 'take a Xanax'. The toxicity of this community is honestly unreal.

You're allowed your opinion, but the way you constructed could've been better tbh. 

"After this snippet I understand why she was so afraid of going back to her roots... Unfortunately, the fear was justified." Like that's just rude and you've only heard 20 seconds out of a 4 minute song. 

[uglysexy 89]

I immediately thought of ARTPOP but the way she speaks is very The Fame. I really like the electronic sounds towards the end of the snippet, I think this one is going to be big

[ManMan 985]

19 minutes ago, Edu said:

#justice4gardenofedenaiversion

 

i like the vibe of this GOE

https://www.bilibili.com/video/BV1Af421q7B6/?spm_id_from=333.337.search-card.all.click&vd_source=ceb59a15040e01cf2970fe8692c84fdb

[AVeryGagaHolyDick 22,760]

1 minute ago, Kayi said:

Private Audition + Reloaded + Out of Control 

This one is for the LMs who know her unreleased songs 

Sending you a hug cause I’m so excited 😭😭😭😭😭

[ModernEcstasy 8,731]

My God this site is gonna be a dumpster fire come Friday. 
Just allow other people to have their opinion.
There’s no need to be offended by it. The song won’t be taken away from you and people can dislike something that you happen to enjoy. 
 

[Luna Lovegood 24,242]

Just heard the snippet, think I’m gonna rest my judgement until I hear the full song 

[Nyctophilus 218]

6 minutes ago, Dramatica said:

There is no intention of being toxic, and I'm sorry if you felt that way.

But it's a thing to say: in my opinion the snippet doesn't sound catchy to me.

A whole other thing to say: this sounds like AI, the lyrics are terribly uncreative.

 

If you are commenting to share how negative you feel about something, why not give it a chance until it's released at least? Or better, no need to spread negativity in here

I really don’t understand the difference between saying that a song doesn’t sound catchy to me and expressing my critique in a more vivid way by saying it sounds like it was written by AI. Both are valid criticisms.

Why should I hold back from criticizing something I don’t like? If others can write essays about why they think the snippet is good, I don’t see why I shouldn’t be allowed to express the opposite opinion, even if it’s just a snippet.

So, expressing opinions in an appropriate manner is considered spreading negativity, but directly calling out a person for their opinion, and implying something about their mental state by mentioning medication used to treat serious disorders like panic attacks and depression is not?

Edited March 5 by Nyctophilus

[Roboboy 3,720]

59 minutes ago, Reality said:

I’m also allowed to think they’re wrong for not liking it  opinions go both ways 

that's different to giving people **** for it like be normal challenge 

[Edu 3,958]

2 minutes ago, ModernEcstasy said:

My God this site is gonna be a dumpster fire come Friday. 
Just allow other people to have their opinion.
There’s no need to be offended by it. The song won’t be taken away from you and people can dislike something that you happen to enjoy. 
 

this

like people are allowed to have different opinions

[AVeryGagaHolyDick 22,760]

Private Audition X The Joker 

[Juanlittlem 43,898]

1 minute ago, ModernEcstasy said:

My God this site is gonna be a dumpster fire come Friday. 
Just allow other people to have their opinion.
There’s no need to be offended by it. The song won’t be taken away from you and people can dislike something that you happen to enjoy. 
 

Ooor how about we dont come here to be a negative nancy and if you dont enjoy the song just avoid commenting on it? Like we should be celebrating new music, if you dont like it thats good to me, I'll still sleep at night but just dont come here to trashtalk a song and an album that isnt even out yet.

[Dramatica 13,578]

Just now, Nyctophilus said:

I really don’t understand the difference between saying that a song doesn’t sound catchy to me and expressing my critique in a more vivid way by saying it sounds like it was written by AI. Both are valid criticisms.

Why should I hold back from criticizing something I don’t like? If others can write essays about why they think the snippet is good, I don’t see why I shouldn’t be allowed to express the opposite opinion, even if it’s just a snippet.

So, expressing opinions in an appropriate manner is considered spreading negativity, but directly calling out a person for their opinion—without even referring to any other user of this forum—and implying something about their mental state by mentioning medication used to treat serious disorders like panic attacks and depression is not?

Both are invalid to me anyways, although you are at right to ask whoever called you out or said you should treat illness / take medicine / whatever, for an apology, cause they owe you one.