Cross Rate The Fame, Joanne, and Chromatica

[Mirrion Rizzons 10,475]

The Fame Monster, Born This Way, and ARTPOP are often considered the holy trinity of Gaga albums. While we wait for Mayhem, I thought it would be fun to cross rate Gaga’s beloved but slightly lower rated works. 
 

1. Just Dance / Diamond Heart / Alice 

- Just Dance takes the win for me here

2. LoveGame / A-YO / Stupid Love 

- LoveGame 

3. Paparazzi / Joanne / Rain On Me

- Paparazzi 

4. Poker Face / John Wayne / Free Woman 

- Poker Face 

5. Eh Eh / Dancin in Circles / Fun Tonight

- Dancin In Circles

6. Beautiful, Dirty, Rich / Perfect Illusion / 911

- 911 

7. The Fame / Million Reasons / Plastic Doll 

- The Fame 

8. Money Honey / Sinner’s Prayer / Sour Candy 

- Sour Candy 

9. Starstruck / Come To Mama / Enigma 

- Enigma 

10. Boys boys boys / Hey Girl / Replay 

- Replay 

11. Paper Gangsta / Angel Down / Sine From Above 

- Angel Down 

12. Brown Eyes / Grigio Girls / 1000 Doves 

- Grigio Girls 

13. I Like It Rough / Just Another Day / Babylon 

- Babylon 

 

Totals: 

The Fame: 5

Chromatica: 5

Joanne: 3

Winners: The Fame + Chromatica 

[27monster27 11,923]

1. Just Dance / Diamond Heart / Alice 

- Just Dance

2. LoveGame / A-YO / Stupid Love 

- LoveGame 

3. Paparazzi / Joanne / Rain On Me

- Paparazzi 

4. Poker Face / John Wayne / Free Woman 

- Poker Face 

5. Eh Eh / Dancin in Circles / Fun Tonight

- Dancin In Circles

6. Beautiful, Dirty, Rich / Perfect Illusion / 911

- 911 

7. The Fame / Million Reasons / Plastic Doll 

- Plastic Doll

8. Money Honey / Sinner’s Prayer / Sour Candy 

- Money Honey

9. Starstruck / Come To Mama / Enigma 

- Enigma 

10. Boys boys boys / Hey Girl / Replay 

- Replay 

11. Paper Gangsta / Angel Down / Sine From Above 

- Paper Gangsta

12. Brown Eyes / Grigio Girls / 1000 Doves 

- Brown Eyes

13. I Like It Rough / Just Another Day / Babylon 

- I Like It Rough

 

Almost the same lol.

My Totals:

The Fame: 9

Joanne: 1

Chromatica: 4

[NUTELLA 4,642]

1. Just Dance / Diamond Heart / Alice 

-JUST DANCE

2. LoveGame / A-YO / Stupid Love 

- LOVEGAME

3. Paparazzi / Joanne / Rain On Me

- PAPARAZZI

4. Poker Face / John Wayne / Free Woman 

- POKER FACE

5. Eh Eh / Dancin in Circles / Fun Tonight

- DANCIN IN CIRCLES

6. Beautiful, Dirty, Rich / Perfect Illusion / 911

- BEAUTIFUL DIRTY RICH

7. The Fame / Million Reasons / Plastic Doll 

- THE FAME

8. Money Honey / Sinner’s Prayer / Sour Candy 

- MONEY HONEY

9. Starstruck / Come To Mama / Enigma 

- STARSTRUCK

10. Boys boys boys / Hey Girl / Replay 

- BOYS BOYS BOYS

11. Paper Gangsta / Angel Down / Sine From Above 

- PAPER GANGSTER

12. Brown Eyes / Grigio Girls / 1000 Doves 

- BROWN EYES

13. I Like It Rough / Just Another Day / Babylon 

- I LIKE IT ROUGH

 

Totals: 

The Fame: 12

Chromatica: 0

Joanne: 1

Winners: THE FAME

[Mirrion Rizzons 10,475]

Just now, 27monster27 said:

1. Just Dance / Diamond Heart / Alice 

- Just Dance

2. LoveGame / A-YO / Stupid Love 

- LoveGame 

3. Paparazzi / Joanne / Rain On Me

- Paparazzi 

4. Poker Face / John Wayne / Free Woman 

- Poker Face 

5. Eh Eh / Dancin in Circles / Fun Tonight

- Dancin In Circles

6. Beautiful, Dirty, Rich / Perfect Illusion / 911

- 911 

7. The Fame / Million Reasons / Plastic Doll 

- Plastic Doll

8. Money Honey / Sinner’s Prayer / Sour Candy 

- Money Honey

9. Starstruck / Come To Mama / Enigma 

- Enigma 

10. Boys boys boys / Hey Girl / Replay 

- Replay 

11. Paper Gangsta / Angel Down / Sine From Above 

- Paper Gangsta

12. Brown Eyes / Grigio Girls / 1000 Doves 

- Brown Eyes

13. I Like It Rough / Just Another Day / Babylon 

- I Like It Rough

 

Almost the same lol.

My Totals:

The Fame: 9

Joanne: 1

Chromatica: 4

I really wanted to include summerboy / work tape / Love me right but I decided against it  the fame would have won 

[Mirrion Rizzons 10,475]

1 minute ago, NUTELLA said:

1. Just Dance / Diamond Heart / Alice 

-JUST DANCE

2. LoveGame / A-YO / Stupid Love 

- LOVEGAME

3. Paparazzi / Joanne / Rain On Me

- PAPARAZZI

4. Poker Face / John Wayne / Free Woman 

- POKER FACE

5. Eh Eh / Dancin in Circles / Fun Tonight

- DANCIN IN CIRCLES

6. Beautiful, Dirty, Rich / Perfect Illusion / 911

- BEAUTIFUL DIRTY RICH

7. The Fame / Million Reasons / Plastic Doll 

- THE FAME

8. Money Honey / Sinner’s Prayer / Sour Candy 

- MONEY HONEY

9. Starstruck / Come To Mama / Enigma 

- STARSTRUCK

10. Boys boys boys / Hey Girl / Replay 

- BOYS BOYS BOYS

11. Paper Gangsta / Angel Down / Sine From Above 

- PAPER GANGSTER

12. Brown Eyes / Grigio Girls / 1000 Doves 

- BROWN EYES

13. I Like It Rough / Just Another Day / Babylon 

- I LIKE IT ROUGH

 

Totals: 

The Fame: 12

Chromatica: 0

Joanne: 1

Winners: THE FAME

You really said cherry cherry boom boom with a hint of yee haw 

[LeafBug 7,808]

1. Just Dance / Diamond Heart / Alice 

- Just Dance 

2. LoveGame / A-YO / Stupid Love 

- LoveGame 

3. Paparazzi / Joanne / Rain On Me

- Rain On Me 

4. Poker Face / John Wayne / Free Woman 

- Free Woman

5. Eh Eh / Dancin in Circles / Fun Tonight

- Fun Tonight

6. Beautiful, Dirty, Rich / Perfect Illusion / 911

- 911 

7. The Fame / Million Reasons / Plastic Doll 

- Plastic Doll

8. Money Honey / Sinner’s Prayer / Sour Candy 

- Sour Candy 

9. Starstruck / Come To Mama / Enigma 

- Enigma 

10. Boys boys boys / Hey Girl / Replay 

- Replay 

11. Paper Gangsta / Angel Down / Sine From Above 

- Angel Down 

12. Brown Eyes / Grigio Girls / 1000 Doves 

- Grigio Girls 

13. I Like It Rough / Just Another Day / Babylon 

- Just Another Day 

 

Totals: 

The Fame: 2

Chromatica: 8

Joanne: 3

Winner: Chromatica 

[Anderson123 36,404]

1. Just Dance / Diamond Heart / Alice 

2. LoveGame / A-YO / Stupid Love 

3. Paparazzi / Joanne / Rain On Me

4. Poker Face / John Wayne / Free Woman 

5. Eh Eh / Dancin in Circles / Fun Tonight

6. Beautiful, Dirty, Rich / Perfect Illusion / 911

7. The Fame / Million Reasons / Plastic Doll 

8. Money Honey / Sinner’s Prayer / Sour Candy

9. Starstruck / Come To Mama / Enigma 

10. Boys boys boys / Hey Girl / Replay 

11. Paper Gangsta / Angel Down / Sine From Above 

12. Brown Eyes / Grigio Girls / 1000 Doves

13. I Like It Rough / Just Another Day / Babylon 

The Fame: 4
Joanne: 2
Chromatica: 7

Had a hard time between Just Dance and Alice, Perfect Illusion and 911 and could’ve picked either. 

[Blackout19 10,793]

1. Just Dance / Diamond Heart / Alice 

2. LoveGame / A-YO / Stupid Love 

3. Paparazzi / Joanne / Rain On Me

4. Poker Face / John Wayne / Free Woman  

5. Eh Eh / Dancin in Circles / Fun Tonight

6. Beautiful, Dirty, Rich / Perfect Illusion / 911

7. The Fame / Million Reasons / Plastic Doll 

8. Money Honey / Sinner’s Prayer / Sour Candy 

9. Starstruck / Come To Mama / Enigma 

10. Boys boys boys / Hey Girl / Replay 

11. Paper Gangsta / Angel Down / Sine From Above 

12. Brown Eyes / Grigio Girls / 1000 Doves 

13. I Like It Rough / Just Another Day / Babylon 

[holy scheisse 21,747]

1. Just Dance

2. LoveGame

3. Paparazzi

4. Poker Face

5. Dancin in Circles 

6. 911

7. Million Reasons

8. Sinner’s Prayer

9. Starstruck

10. Replay 

11. Paper Gangsta

12. 1000 Doves 

13. I Like It Rough

 

The Fame- 7
Joanne- 3
Chromatica- 3

[eifulien 2,516]

Okay, let's do it.

1. Just Dance / Diamond Heart / Alice - very tough, she always starts strong

2. LoveGame / A-YO / Stupid Love - super easy, the other two are very meh

3. Paparazzi / Joanne / Rain On Me - almost impossible to choose, I think Joanne is the most beautiful tho

4. Poker Face / John Wayne / Free Woman - WOW, John Wayne and Free Woman are like my second favourites of their respective albums, giving it to Chromatica because of no. 3

5. Eh, Eh / Dancin in Circles / Fun Tonight - one of my fave Gaga songs, super sweet and underrated

6. Beautiful, Dirty, Rich / Perfect Illusion / 911 - probably my second fave lead after Disease

7. The Fame / Million Reasons / Plastic Doll - I hate MR and PD with passion, TF is at least cute

8. Money Honey / Sinner’s Prayer / Sour Candy - easy, top 5 Gaga for me

9. Starstruck / Come To Mama / Enigma - easy, one of the few songs I can still listen to from Chromatica

10. Boys boys boys / Hey Girl / Replay - not as obsessed as the fanbase about it, but the other two aren't really any competition

11. Paper Gangsta / Angel Down / Sine From Above - beautiful song!

12. Brown Eyes / Grigio Girls / 1000 Doves - the 1000 Doves piano would have won, but the album version is meh, I hate GG with passion

13. I Like It Rough / Just Another Day / Babylon - JAD is one of my faves, and I'm realising now how I really prefer Joanne over Chromatica, not sure I was even aware of it til now.

Totals:
The Fame: 4
Joanne: 5
Chromatica: 4

Winner: Joanne 

Edited 15 hours ago by eifulien

[qoqo 3,282]

Lemme find a spot for my babies Summerboy and Disco Heaven as well
 

1. Just Dance / Diamond Heart / Alice 

2. LoveGame / A-YO / Stupid Love 

3. Paparazzi / Joanne / Rain On Me

4. Poker Face / John Wayne / Free Woman 

5. Eh Eh / Dancin in Circles / Fun Tonight

6. Beautiful, Dirty, Rich / Perfect Illusion / 911

7. The Fame / Million Reasons / Plastic Doll 

8. Money Honey / Sinner’s Prayer / Sour Candy 

9. Starstruck / Come To Mama / Enigma 

10. Boys boys boys / Hey Girl / Replay 

11. Paper Gangsta / Angel Down / Sine From Above 

12. Brown Eyes / Grigio Girls / 1000 Doves 

13. I Like It Rough / Just Another Day / Babylon 

14. Summerboy / Angel Down work tape / Love Me Right

15. Disco Heaven / Million Reasons work tape / 100 Doves demo

The Fame: 9 🥇 

Joanne: 4 🥈 

Chromatica: 2 🥉 

[princedeeblebleble 866]

1. Just Dance / Diamond Heart / Alice 

2. LoveGame / A-YO / Stupid Love 

3. Paparazzi / Joanne / Rain On Me

4. Poker Face / John Wayne / Free Woman (Free woman if we count the fan remix)

5. Eh Eh / Dancin in Circles / Fun Tonight

6. Beautiful, Dirty, Rich / Perfect Illusion / 911

 7. The Fame / Million Reasons / Plastic Doll 

8. Money Honey / Sinner’s Prayer / Sour Candy 

9. Starstruck / Come To Mama / Enigma 

10. Boys boys boys / Hey Girl / Replay 

11. Paper Gangsta / Angel Down / Sine From Above

12. Brown Eyes / Grigio Girls / 1000 Doves 

13. I Like It Rough / Just Another Day / Babylon 

Chromatica 9

Joanne 2

The Fame 2

[Sunday 2,148]

1. Just Dance / Diamond Heart / Alice 

2. LoveGame / A-YO / Stupid Love 

3. Paparazzi / Joanne / Rain On Me

4. Poker Face / John Wayne / Free Woman 

5. Eh Eh / Dancin in Circles / Fun Tonight

6. Beautiful, Dirty, Rich / Perfect Illusion / 911

7. The Fame / Million Reasons / Plastic Doll 

8. Money Honey / Sinner’s Prayer / Sour Candy

9. Starstruck / Come To Mama / Enigma 

10. Boys boys boys / Hey Girl / Replay 

11. Paper Gangsta / Angel Down / Sine From Above 

12. Brown Eyes / Grigio Girls / 1000 Doves

13. I Like It Rough / Just Another Day / Babylon 

The Fame: 8
Joanne: 4
Chromatica: 3

How dare y'all make me choose between Hey Girl/Replay and on JAD/Babylon  I could not bring myself to choose just one.

It's fine eitherway, I knew The Fame would win from the getgo. 

[Celloo Deng 53,917]

1. Just Dance / Diamond Heart / Alice 

2. LoveGame / A-YO / Stupid Love 

3. Paparazzi / Joanne / Rain On Me

4. Poker Face / John Wayne / Free Woman 

5. Eh Eh / Dancin in Circles / Fun Tonight

6. Beautiful, Dirty, Rich / Perfect Illusion / 911

7. The Fame / Million Reasons / Plastic Doll 

8. Money Honey / Sinner’s Prayer / Sour Candy 

9. Starstruck / Come To Mama / Enigma 

10. Boys boys boys / Hey Girl / Replay 

11. Paper Gangsta / Angel Down / Sine From Above 

12. Brown Eyes / Grigio Girls / 1000 Doves 

13. I Like It Rough / Just Another Day / Babylon 

 

The Fame: 8

Chromatica: 5

Joanne: 0

[FfFfFfFF 54,411]

You must really hate Hoenne to set ha up like this.