Unpopular Gaga Opinions (The Re-Up: Pt. 2 - the Revenge) [Piano Version]

[River 105,847]

Just now, culturalbaptism said:

More like la isla bonita, a classique we can definitely get behind 

not at all la isla Juanita sounds like Don't Turn Around.

[PartySick 146,035]

1 minute ago, River said:

Alejandro sounds like Madonna's Die Another Day

It also sounds like Thriller except for the strings, synths, bass, percussion, and melodies.

Like, if you mute it they're identical and honestly I think that's pretty damning

[River 105,847]

4 minutes ago, PartySick said:

It also sounds like Thriller except for the strings, synths, bass, percussion, and melodies.

Like, if you mute it they're identical and honestly I think that's pretty damning

exactly, u tell em Carly

[bionic 43,173]

11 minutes ago, PartySick said:

It also sounds like Thriller except for the strings, synths, bass, percussion, and melodies.

Like, if you mute it they're identical and honestly I think that's pretty damning

[bionic 43,173]

20 minutes ago, River said:

Alejandro sounds like Madonna's Die Another Day

the gold mods really in this thread just saying anything that comes to mind

what are they serving at the ggd mod xmas meal

Edited Wednesday at 08:45 PM by bionic

[River 105,847]

30 minutes ago, bionic said:

the gold mods really in this thread just saying anything that comes to mind

what are they serving at the ggd mod xmas meal

@Rat Boy they are dissing your food again

[A Very Gaga Holida 20,897]

2 hours ago, Decodekid said:

I love Disease but it is not the groundbreaking best lead single y’all say it is, you are all just surprised it’s dark pop again I’m sorry  some of you didn’t appreciate Chromatica enough to understand that was her pop comeback but ok 

Literally nobody was surprised that Disease was dark pop, what surprised us is how good it is compared to anything from Chromatica 

Edited Wednesday at 09:21 PM by A Very Gaga Holida

[Rat Boy 41,626]

7 minutes ago, River said:

@Rat Boy they are dissing your food again

he stans bionic...enough said. 

[LadyEnigma 1,061]

Idk if this is unpopular but Chromatica is BY FAR her worst produced project, all of the songs would be significantly better with a different producer imo…I honestly think this is just a me thing but when I can hear white noise behind the track it ruins the song for me and I have that problem with amazing songs like Replay and Babylon also some songs straight up needed a different vibe (Free Woman, Stupid Love) and 911 could’ve went HARDER there’s just stuff I’d change everywhere and while I still love Chromatica for what it is that’s my unpopular opinion lmao.

[SevenWonder 3,800]

The Fame is her least interesting album to me. Kinda by far. I never listen to it as an album. While I like and appreciate JD, PF and LoveGame, they are also her least interesting "hits" to me in her entire catalogue of hits. 

(I do LOVE Paparazzi, however, and it's the only song I do listen to.)

[Sugar Baby 760]

The Christiaca Ball was kinda bad 

the stage is literally the same the entire show and the outfits do not feel chromatica at all only the Alíen one during the piano segment and even that is flat when she takes the mask on 

I wanted to see purple/pink wigs and outfits similar to the ones she wore in the stupid love video and chromatica Photoshoot

[gagzus 14,598]

I kinda wish she’d lent into the whole “bitchy delusional diva” image more that she started getting in late 2012. 

She always had this attitude of I’m amazing and unique and better than every other pop star, that I loved EVEN during her debut. The way she spoke about ARTPOP is exactly how convoluted she talked about The Fame (many of y’all fail to realise that because you just weren’t THERE when she was debuting)
 

I think she is the LAST true artist of our generation, not a single pop star or even indie star I’ve seen since her debut has ever measured upto her.

She should stick to doing exclusively dance music or exclusively jazz music (id buy any and all of it) because she was on track to revive jazz’s appeal or be the queen of Dance back in the day.

i think she should also take a LONG hiatus after this album and come back in 10 years or so.

[gagzus 14,598]

29 minutes ago, LadyEnigma said:

Idk if this is unpopular but Chromatica is BY FAR her worst produced project, all of the songs would be significantly better with a different producer imo…I honestly think this is just a me thing but when I can hear white noise behind the track it ruins the song for me and I have that problem with amazing songs like Replay and Babylon also some songs straight up needed a different vibe (Free Woman, Stupid Love) and 911 could’ve went HARDER there’s just stuff I’d change everywhere and while I still love Chromatica for what it is that’s my unpopular opinion lmao.

It still irritates me hearing the demos for FW and ROM and how truly 90s they sounded and felt and how she just threw away Boyz Noise’s organic production  

[crazygato 449]

Born This Way and Judas are CRINGE songs, with the worst offender being Judas (lol).

But let’s be honest, it was BTW that turned the GP off, not Judas. It was definitely more controversial than Judas. NEVER seen a group /party of young people play that song EVER! Or anyone who says “it’s my fave song” other than online/youtube comments. Can’t believe her team thought they were making history releasing them back to back. I LOVE it as the lead single and glad for the controversy it caused at the time but she had to follow it up with something GREAT and fresh sounding like MTN, TEOG, or even You And I! Not a calculated rehash of her previous hits (Judas). The baptism/ betrayal thing was also pretentious and it was at that point that her and her label bought into their own hype instead of letting the music speak for itself. Everything felt so calculated until it wasn’t and turned into a mess, affecting the performance of great songs like TEOG and MTN. 

[compassionhills 57]

i would actually really LOVE gaga to do a full original jazz album, all new songs written by her. it would be great and i think she would be really passionate about it, and we know she can write jazz music because when she's remixed her older songs into jazz versions they've always sounded great