Antidote or Poison? Which is the better live version of Disease?

[Raivo 129]

3 hours ago, CubbyGaga said:

The antidote!  I love this new era and single so much, but honestly I didn't see the point of the Poison version.  It’s not much different from the antidote.  I feel the the poison should’ve been a hard rock version.  

Exactly my thought, she could have pushed more in rock/ hard rock version. But still Poision is my fave. But both are great and in my playlost ofc.

[ceminay 485]

Poison. That guitar is just everything…

[Psyduck 1,072]

Something about Gaga and a piano that encapsulates me

[GoldenPonyboy 2,268]

The poison version not being a full on rock version is the biggest missed opportunity of her career along with telephone part 3

[ThisGuyTony 29,038]

The Antidote of course 

I never heard The Poison version after my initial listen

[Real Panda 7,585]

Antidote

There are parts of Poison I dont like, a few parts sound "squeaky" if that makes sense. The Antidote version is so much better. It sounds haunting and shows how Gaga can easily switch up different vocal placements.

[Killa 15,504]

1 hour ago, PartySick said:

When I first heard the poison version I was mad there weren't any growls or minor belts like in Happy Mistake. Total missed opportunity.

Omg this After Happy mistake... If there was a Song for distortion would be this One like...why

 

[KennyRichie 1,749]

Even though there are slightly better arguments for Antidote, they are currently on a tie in the poll

[zebrastripes 945]

I get like a Massive Attack vibe from the Antidote one and it's a lot more grounded, I feel.