Antidote or Poison? Which is the better live version of Disease?

[Raivo 136]

3 hours ago, CubbyGaga said:

The antidote!  I love this new era and single so much, but honestly I didn't see the point of the Poison version.  It’s not much different from the antidote.  I feel the the poison should’ve been a hard rock version.  

Exactly my thought, she could have pushed more in rock/ hard rock version. But still Poision is my fave. But both are great and in my playlost ofc.

[ceminay 506]

Poison. That guitar is just everything…

[Psyduck 1,081]

Something about Gaga and a piano that encapsulates me

[GoldenPonyboy 2,273]

The poison version not being a full on rock version is the biggest missed opportunity of her career along with telephone part 3

[ThisGuyTony 29,069]

The Antidote of course 

I never heard The Poison version after my initial listen

[Real Panda 7,598]

Antidote

There are parts of Poison I dont like, a few parts sound "squeaky" if that makes sense. The Antidote version is so much better. It sounds haunting and shows how Gaga can easily switch up different vocal placements.

[Killa 15,534]

1 hour ago, PartySick said:

When I first heard the poison version I was mad there weren't any growls or minor belts like in Happy Mistake. Total missed opportunity.

Omg this After Happy mistake... If there was a Song for distortion would be this One like...why

 

[KennyRichie 1,758]

Even though there are slightly better arguments for Antidote, they are currently on a tie in the poll

[zebrastripes 947]

I get like a Massive Attack vibe from the Antidote one and it's a lot more grounded, I feel.

[newtti 104]

Poison!

The antidote is quite bland and I didn't like it, whereas vocals on poison are much cooler for me

[Controversiaga 9,255]

Antidote wasn’t my cup of tea so I didn’t bother listening to poison 

[ManMan 837]

Gen 10 confirmed 

Pokemon Poison & Pokemon Atidote

Boxart Legendary for Poison = Gaga the K totally unique, Antidote = Lady the Never the same

 

 

[AnglerfishbraBENUS 5,527]

8 hours ago, Linus Gaga said:

Prefer the leaked version unfortunately 

this. it’s so good 

[KennyRichie 1,758]

It still is a tie, with 47 votes each

[Ladle Ghoulash 16,210]

4 hours ago, AnglerfishbraBENUS said:

this. it’s so good 

Imo the vocals on the leaked version are the weakest of them all. Sis was pitchy, gasping for air, and they had clearly pitch corrected them. Poison is pretty good, but imo, Antidote clears the other two with ease