Thoughts on Disease?

[Auralegends 4,902]

Love it, it's also very catchy but I'm not sure how it will perform

[Rat Boy 41,688]

Just now, River said:

@Rat Boy I SAW IT

My comment in a deleted thread?

[Monstermilo 3,792]

its decent 

its not bad romance level but for us fans i think its good

unfortunately i think the GPs over gagas pop material. they wanna hear ASIB/DWAS type of music that shows off her talent. i do not see this charting well at all - i hope im wrong but it sounds like a promo single to me and not lead single material. with each listen it grows on me, and its more interesting sonically and vocally than anything on todays radio, but its not exactly smash hit material, more like a deep cut that her harcore fans will love

[lastpopicon 4,259]

dark pop perfection, and call me insane but bad romance levels of brilliance

 

it's so addicting 

[The Fame Monster 3,872]

I absolutely love it! I can already tell it’s going to grow on me even more. I can’t wait for the music video, and especially the first live performance! Hopefully, we’ll get both soon.

[River 106,040]

1 minute ago, Rat Boy said:

My comment in a deleted thread?

your vote, i'll check the comment out

 

I'm gonna flush you back to where you came from, choose looka looka over die sis

[Rat Boy 41,688]

Just now, River said:

your vote, i'll check the comment out

 

I'm gonna flush you back to where you came from, choose looka looka over die sis

My vote was positive

I think you will love my deleted comment

[SimonBaetens 6,881]

I like it but I'm not obsessed with it yet.

[Monstermilo 3,792]

i like it but i also feel underwhelmed if that makes sense - its been 4 years since her last pop record and i def think she couldve come up with something more undeniably good - i feel the same way i felt about stupid love, i feel like its a good song but its nowhere near as good as her old hits. 

[River 106,040]

Just now, Rat Boy said:

My vote was positive

I think you will love my deleted comment

checking your profile like a creepy stalker AS WE SPEAK

[The Fame Monster 3,872]

1 minute ago, Monstermilo said:

unfortunately i think the GPs over gagas pop material. they wanna hear ASIB/DWAS type of music that shows off her talent.

I'm sorry you feel that way, but honestly, who cares about the charts and general public opinion?  We don’t need mainstream approval to appreciate the song. It doesn’t have to be a #1 hit to prove it’s a great song! 

I hope the song grows on you. 

[Darcklighter22 2,293]

Well, I listened to it several times and avoided coming online to taint any feelings towards the song. Wasn't disappointed!

The beat slaps, it's different. She does thing vocals she has never done she wasn't lying. 

This is absolutely where I was hoping she would go sonically so... bring on LG7! 

[Monstermilo 3,792]

i honestly feel like this will perform like the cure 

the fans will love it, but it will flop commercially - prolly peak top 30 or top 20

i would love for a top 10 debut but idkkk its not exactly radio friendly 

[Mindblown 6,708]

I don’t know why but part of the song it reminds me HEAVILY of Rock Me by One Direction. Maybe I’m just dumb lol

Anyways, I love it. I'm hoping for a club remix of Disease that's slightly more crazy and shorter in length. 

One Direction - Rock Me

Time: 1:24 - 1:45

 

Lady Gaga - Disease 

Time: 0:59 - 1:08

 

 

Edited October 25, 2024 by Mindblown

[Monstermilo 3,792]

1 minute ago, The Fame Monster said:

I'm sorry you feel that way, but honestly, who cares about the charts and general public opinion?  We don’t need mainstream approval to appreciate the song. It doesn’t have to be a #1 hit to prove it’s a great song! 

I hope the song grows on you. 

i actually like the song - its perfect for spooky season but i just know the GP wont like it like DWAS 

and after joker flopping i was really hoping for a win for gaga but we shall see as time goes by