HARLEQUIN 70 on MC

[Ladymars 3,650]

65 on MC

Edited October 4, 2024 by Ladymars

[thierryrreiht 20,942]

That seems… low?

[Nycboy 1,045]

Why is it not at least an 80! I feel like this could be her strongest vocal work & strongest display of musical passion 

[Ladymars 3,650]

Just now, thierryrreiht said:

That seems… low?

Not bad for a side project 

also it will most probably rise as more reviews get added

[REALITY 75,616]

Gaga’s Metacritic ratings have always been fairly low. Out of her solo albums, Chromatica’s the highest and that’s at 79. TF has a 71, TFM has a 78, BTW has a 71, ARTPOP has a 61, and Joanne has a 67. They’re all too low imo 

[connorfilm 7,281]

Just now, Reality said:

Gaga’s Metacritic ratings have always been fairly low. Out of her solo albums, Chromatica’s the highest and that’s at 79. TF has a 71, TFM has a 78, BTW has a 71, ARTPOP has a 61, and Joanne has a 67. They’re all too low imo 

C2C is 64 and LFS is 70. Oh, and the ASIB soundtrack is 78.

[63grekke 1,440]

9 minutes ago, Ladymars said:

Not bad for a side project 

[mamo 18,478]

Let's just face it...Gaga's held to a much higher standard than most of her peers and the industry. She just can't seem to win or catch a break with whatever she puts out. It's annoying because Gaga is a once-in-a-lifetime artist and talent like hers is taken too much for granted especially in a time where true artistry is extremely rare. 

Also if Taylor Swift or Beyoncé or literally anyone else dropped this body of work, it would be critically acclaimed and lauded. Personally, I'm just glad Gaga is happy and has found joy in creating music and art again. That's really all that matters to me as a fan. 

 

Edited September 27, 2024 by mamo

[nodandsmile 10,100]

13 minutes ago, thierryrreiht said:

That seems… low?

for her... not really, music critics don't f*ck with her like that!

[River 112,844]

most of them are just bitter people who listens to trash music, so jazz is giving them a cultural shock

[gfarabello 599]

3 minutes ago, mamo said:

let's just face it...Gaga's held to a much higher standard than most of her peers and the industry. she just can't seem to win or catch a break with whatever she puts out. it's annoying because Gaga is a once in a lifetime artist and talent like hers is taken too much for granted in a time where true artistry is extremely rare. 

also if taylor swift or beyoncé or literally anyone else dropped this body of work, it would be critically acclaimed and lauded. personally, I'm just glad Gaga is happy and found joy in creating music/art again. that's all that matters to me as a fan. 

 

Agreed. This album is equivalent to Beyonce's Cowboy Carter in terms of genre-crossing, which got a 91 on metacritic.

[metalguru 1,514]

1 minute ago, gfarabello said:

Agreed. This album is equivalent to Beyonce's Cowboy Carter in terms of genre-crossing, which got a 91 on metacritic.

No it is not. It doesn’t have to be.

And yes, this album deserved a solid 80. 

[gemein3 1,257]

Also, it also only has a handful of reviews as of typing this lol.

Not saying it’ll dramatically change, but chill….

[Roughhouse Dandy 10,606]

For a companion concept piece to a comic book film full of jazz, gospel, and broadway covers? I'll take it. 

[Ladymars 3,650]

8 minutes ago, gemein3 said:

Also, it also only has a handful of reviews as of typing this lol.

Not saying it’ll dramatically change, but chill….

I’m expecting it to rise above 70 which is a decent score if you ask me