Katy Perry's 143 up to 37 on Metacritic

[robotvoiceinalice 1,179]

6 minutes ago, Luna Lovegood said:

Metacritic's Worst Rated Albums Ever:
 

1. Kevin Federline – "Play with Fire" (2006) – [16]

2. Bloodhound Gang – "Hefty Fine" (2006) – [28]
3. The Pigeon Detectives – "We Met At Sea" (2013) – [29]
4. Young Rebel Set – "Curse Our Love" (2011) – [32]

4. The Twang – "Neotwang" (2014) – [32]

5. Limp Bizkit – "Results May Vary" (2003) – [33]
6. Viva Brother – "Famous First Words" (2011) – [34]
7. Phil Collins – "Testify" (2002) – [34]

8. Katy Perry – "143" (2024) – [34] (+4) New Peak 
9. Dirty Vegas – "One" (2004) – [35]
10. Juliana Hatfield – "Juliana's Pony" (2000) – [35]
11. Theory of a Deadman – "The Truth Is" (2011) – [35]
12. Tulisa – "Female Boss" (2012) – [35]

weren't like all these albums career ending?

[Killa 16,402]

Rolling Stones seemed serene in tone

[StarstruckIllusion 51,543]

Why do I feel like Pitchfork is about to save this catastrophe and drop a 6.6 or whatever 

[Bronco 7,649]

23 hours ago, stevana229 said:

I just can't believe this is the same woman who created the Teenage Dream album... like HUH? It makes me think all her songs were handed to her and she only changed a word or two. Justice for Bonnie McKee

I mean its been said in interviews that the concept and thematic direction of TD was essentially all Bonnie McKee's doing and Katy didnt even like her 😂

Honestly Katy's ego has always been her biggest enemy. 

[Bronco 7,649]

1 hour ago, robotvoiceinalice said:

weren't like all these albums career ending?

Basically.

Limp Biskit didnt put out a new studio album for like 7 years after.

Phil Collins announced it was his last studio album. And has only released 1 album since which was of Mowtown covers.

And they're like the only 2 actual names on that list besides Katy tbh

[ThisGuyTony 29,392]

44 minutes ago, StarstruckIllusion said:

Why do I feel like Pitchfork is about to save this catastrophe and drop a 6.6 or whatever 

They dragged Woman’s World. I fear they’re about to drop a bomb 0/10 score

[butthole 9,958]

2 hours ago, robotvoiceinalice said:

weren't like all these albums career ending?

Limp Bizkit is still touring. I'd imagine it's probably like small state fairs and wedding receptions, so that's something nice for Katy to look forward to.

[Mister G 10,236]

41 minutes ago, Bronco said:

I mean its been said in interviews that the concept and thematic direction of TD was essentially all Bonnie McKee's doing and Katy didnt even like her 😂

Honestly Katy's ego has always been her biggest enemy. 

Preach. That's why when people ask me in my group of friends why I don't mess with her, it's because for me something about her doesn't feel genuine in terms of how she views the world or even others around her. And when she basically looked the other way during Kesha's legal battles with Dr. Puke back in 2016, 2017, I lost all respect for her as an individual because she almost made a mockery out of that entire situation. Her ego showed in full force during that Witness era and honestly I don't feel bad for her because humility would have done wonders for her.

[robotvoiceinalice 1,179]

8 minutes ago, hieronymus said:

Limp Bizkit is still touring. I'd imagine it's probably like small state fairs and wedding receptions, so that's something nice for Katy to look forward to.

 

[StarstruckIllusion 51,543]

On 9/20/2024 at 3:28 PM, stevana229 said:

I just can't believe this is the same woman who created the Teenage Dream album... like HUH? It makes me think all her songs were handed to her and she only changed a word or two. Justice for Bonnie McKee

If you listen to Bonnie’s new solo album… it’s obvious she was the secret sauce for Katy, and NOT Dr. Luke. 

But Katy has one sided beef with her so the fact she chose Luke is even more ridiculous

[LateToCult 40,287]

On 9/20/2024 at 11:02 AM, LateToCult said:

It’s never good when your rating is closer to an ACT score. 

You know, many high school kids would be over the moon to get an ACT score of 34. So, I guess you could say 143 truly is a…teenage dream. 

I’ll see myself out.

[Teletubby 140,025]

26 minutes ago, StarstruckIllusion said:

If you listen to Bonnie’s new solo album… it’s obvious she was the secret sauce for Katy, and NOT Dr. Luke. 

So why doesn't she get any hits herself?

people were saying Katy owed all her success to Luke, and now they say she owes it to Bonnie and that's not true. if anything she should move on from all her old collaborators and not try to recreate Prism or Teenage Dream.

Edited September 21, 2024 by Teletubby

[GagaGame 3,359]

3 minutes ago, Teletubby said:

not try to recreate Prism or Teenage Dream.

this! just explore different genres! you can go on ur joanne era, or on your asib era 

[Bronco 7,649]

8 minutes ago, Teletubby said:

So why doesn't she get any hits herself?

people were saying Katy owed all her success to Luke, and now they say she owes her success it to Bonnie and that's not true. if anything she should move on from all her old collaborators and not try to recreate Prism or Teenage Dream.

I mean that's an easy one. 

Money. 

Chart performance requires significant label backing. And it's pretty common fair for go to hit writers to get locked into writing for others by labels instead of having solo careers. 

[StarstruckIllusion 51,543]

53 minutes ago, Teletubby said:

So why doesn't she get any hits herself?

people were saying Katy owed all her success to Luke, and now they say she owes it to Bonnie and that's not true. if anything she should move on from all her old collaborators and not try to recreate Prism or Teenage Dream.

Hits =\= good music, obviously 

Her sound is just way more Teenage Dream coded than Katy’s atp

Ig people credited Dr. Puke bc he’s had hits with other artists but clearly in 2024 Puke and Katy lost the touch but Bonnie is still serving