Gaga: singing in JFAD "unlike anything I’ve ever done before"

[Bronco 2,749]

17 minutes ago, Head Empty said:

I can't wait for her to talk about all the other artists she studied in order to learn singing without any talent or technique 

Katy Perry just can't win this era 

[Anderson123 33,017]

This is very interesting because it's not going to be like Ally that every time she sang you were just looking at Gaga singing like Gaga. With Lee it seems like the insanity of the character is going to be very present in the not so perfect notes that she does.

[LG7 time now 18,562]

18 minutes ago, DrKindnessKunt1999 said:

It's fascinating to see how Lady Gaga can create distinct vocal identities for each character she portrays in films. She did it with Ally she's doing it with Lee, and in the future, she'll continue to develop unique voices for her roles.

In the future he’s going to have an extensive discography of albums created by different characters. 

I don’t think she did it with Ally  Her singing was her singing, especially in ARUTW, not to mention the melody in Shallow which screams Gaga  Ally is a trained singer, Lee is just another girl who will have to sing because her therapists ask her to do so 

[Chlorine 46,325]

35 minutes ago, LastNight said:

I see it being a mix. Any non-fantasy singing (like Get Happy at the end of the trailer) will probably be the messier vocals that flow with the dialogue and fit with the scene. It looks like there’s some kind of choir practice or music therapy at the asylum, so it will probably make sense in context. And then when they’re in fantasies they’re both completely transformed; it’s a proper performance with them singing well.

Sort of how when they’re waltzing through the street in real life it’s a bit haphazard, but when we see them waltz in the fantasy sequence it’s very poised and elegant.

32 minutes ago, Edonis said:

nnnn we will have to wait and see, but that's also what I'm kind of getting from this. 

 

Though, I do think there is at least some fantasy to it. Maybe Joker and Harley are taking music therapy and that's where the singing aspect comes into play.

My theory 

Spoiler

It will start off as the fantasy / shared delusion and start leaking out into real life as they both plunge further into madness, the same way Joker can't control his laughing outbursts. Imagine how uncanny and disturbing it will be to see them singing as if they are in a musical – but off-key, etc – while committing gruesome acts, because they are ****ing insane. Omg. 

 

[TimotheeChalamet 3,544]

21 minutes ago, LG7 time now said:

I don’t think she did it with Ally  Her singing was her singing, especially in ARUTW, not to mention the melody in Shallow which screams Gaga  Ally is a trained singer, Lee is just another girl who will have to sing because her therapists ask her to do so 

She sang in a thinner voice especially in Ally's pop songs though, reflecting the way she gets manufactured by the industry 

Edited 4 hours ago by TimotheeChalamet

[AndiGaga 5,405]

37 minutes ago, Lextyr97 said:

She can say that but her singing from the leaks on the stairs was one of the greatest things I’ve ever heard come out of her mouth. ****ing immaculate 

Wheeeere is this leak

[LG7 time now 18,562]

8 minutes ago, AndiGaga said:

Wheeeere is this leak

Everywhere on YouTube, singing That’s Entertainment

[VTV 11,216]

i kept wondering who is Lee then I realized its Harlee quinn?

[LG7 time now 18,562]

46 minutes ago, Lextyr97 said:

She can say that but her singing from the leaks on the stairs was one of the greatest things I’ve ever heard come out of her mouth. ****ing immaculate 

I forgot about that omg, TRUE, her voice in that scene is fabulous 

[Bradley 55,741]

1 hour ago, Head Empty said:

I can't wait for her to talk about all the other artists she studied in order to learn singing without any talent or technique 

"I studied Katy Perry to sing off-key."

[Bowman 6,889]

14 minutes ago, VTV said:

i kept wondering who is Lee then I realized its Harlee quinn?

I believe that the (director?) said that she wanted to be called Lee on set and felt more in character 

[EGOT2027 10,562]

the average viewer will not pick up that she’s missing notes on purpose 

[Borisapillar 7,080]

1 hour ago, Head Empty said:

I can't wait for her to talk about all the other artists she studied in order to learn singing without any talent or technique 

Katy will finally have her moment 

 

edit- y’all beat me

Edited 2 hours ago by Borisapillar

[Bradley 55,741]

17 minutes ago, EGOT2027 said:

the average viewer will not pick up that she’s missing notes on purpose 

It will be felt even if it's not consciously registered.

[Plastic Flower 2,698]

27 minutes ago, EGOT2027 said:

the average viewer will not pick up that she’s missing notes on purpose 

Love her or hate her, everyone knows she can sing so that's not a problem imo.