nATAH 49,833 Posted July 28, 2023 Share Posted July 28, 2023 i don't see how it wouldn't fit, ally could easily say she once wrote a song about her aunt mother, what must i do? Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
voltron92 2,390 Posted July 28, 2023 Share Posted July 28, 2023 1 hour ago, Maxine Puth said: And then we get a 20 minute subplot about how Ally’s aunt Joanne dies and it makes her give up her dreams of becoming a star, that is until she finds a letter written by her which makes her realize that she wouldn’t want Ally giving up on her career. Fast forward, Ally would play her new song, Joanne, to her grandma who seemed very confused and nonchalant. Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
CAPRISONGS 1,631 Posted July 28, 2023 Share Posted July 28, 2023 this is so random, if it was something like Diamond Heart, it would make more sense Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Controversiaga 11,315 Posted July 28, 2023 Share Posted July 28, 2023 Y’all the song would’ve been rewritten lyrically to fit the story lol they would’ve removed the name “Joanne” and probably replaced it with Jackson or again it could’ve been completely rewritten and Bradley just wanted the music and melody Pronounced like “Balenciaga” . Emphasis on the “Ga” Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Anderson123 38,475 Posted July 28, 2023 Share Posted July 28, 2023 Not y'all thinking Ally or Jackson would've sung about their dead aunt Joanne. I think it's pretty obvious they'd have changed the lyrics to make it fit into the storyline. Think of "Maybe It's Time" for example. Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Red 98,021 Posted July 28, 2023 Share Posted July 28, 2023 3 minutes ago, Controversiaga said: Y’all the song would’ve been rewritten lyrically to fit the story lol they would’ve removed the name “Joanne” and probably replaced it with Jackson or again it could’ve been completely rewritten and Bradley just wanted the music and melody 2 minutes ago, Anderson123 said: Not y'all thinking Ally or Jackson would've sung about their dead aunt Joanne. I think it's pretty obvious they'd have changed the lyrics to make it fit into the storyline. Think of "Maybe It's Time" for example. They would actually have to change the story too cause the song consists in thoughts of someone who loves a person that is about to die and there's not one moment in the movie where Ally talks to Jackson knowing he's about to die, she's not there when he decides it If you see me posting like crazy, I'm either bored or procrastinating. Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Anderson123 38,475 Posted July 28, 2023 Share Posted July 28, 2023 2 minutes ago, Red said: They would actually have to change the story too cause the song consists in thoughts of someone who loves a person that is about to die and there's not one moment in the movie where Ally talks to Jackson knowing he's about to die, she's not there when he decides it Maybe they'd have kept the melody/instrumental and completely write the lyrics from scratch. Shallow also has some lyrics about water and drowning which was Jackson's original death and they still kept those in there after they changed it. Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Controversiaga 11,315 Posted July 28, 2023 Share Posted July 28, 2023 11 minutes ago, Red said: They would actually have to change the story too cause the song consists in thoughts of someone who loves a person that is about to die and there's not one moment in the movie where Ally talks to Jackson knowing he's about to die, she's not there when he decides it The song is about someone who has been dead for decades though Pronounced like “Balenciaga” . Emphasis on the “Ga” Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Ladle Ghoulash 25,261 Posted July 28, 2023 Share Posted July 28, 2023 1 minute ago, Controversiaga said: The song is about someone who has been dead for decades though Sure, but it’s written from the POV of someone watching them die in real time We have forgotten our public MANNERS Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Controversiaga 11,315 Posted July 28, 2023 Share Posted July 28, 2023 2 minutes ago, deactivated001 said: Sure, but it’s written from the POV of someone watching them die in real time But don’t you think they could adapt that same actual concept for the movie? Pronounced like “Balenciaga” . Emphasis on the “Ga” Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Ladle Ghoulash 25,261 Posted July 28, 2023 Share Posted July 28, 2023 11 minutes ago, Controversiaga said: But don’t you think they could adapt that same actual concept for the movie? You could do it either way, tbh. We have forgotten our public MANNERS Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Edonis 28,950 Posted July 28, 2023 Share Posted July 28, 2023 29 minutes ago, Red said: They would actually have to change the story too cause the song consists in thoughts of someone who loves a person that is about to die and there's not one moment in the movie where Ally talks to Jackson knowing he's about to die, she's not there when he decides it If Gaga agreed to use Joanne’s demo in the film, the only thing that would remain is the melody and maybe the instrumental. It’s not uncommon for people to buy demos just for the melody to later rewrite the song from scratch. Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Jnick8 530 Posted July 28, 2023 Share Posted July 28, 2023 This would have fit if Jackson was singing it with a few changes to lyrics 🥰 Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Madame Goo Goo 3,870 Posted July 28, 2023 Share Posted July 28, 2023 2 hours ago, AnglerfishbraBENUS said: So this confirms Shallow isn’t a Joanne outtake which is good to know, but definitely curious if anything else was If it ever came out that Shallow was a Joanne outtake, Gaga would have her Oscar taken away so it was basically already confirmed lol Lady Gaga doesn't owe us anything Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Ivy 12,591 Posted July 28, 2023 Share Posted July 28, 2023 The sound would fit in the movie tbh Just change "Joanne" to "my love" or something, and girl to boy, and it fits at the end of the movie the meow in zombieboy Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Featured Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.