Fernando Garibay produced my favorite Gaga songs

[Kimmo 81,120]

I know there’s been a little controversy between him, Gaga and DJWS after the BTW/ Madonna mess so I don’t expect them working ever again, but he did that gheys not only did he produced he also help write some of them 

Dance In The Dark

Bloody Mary (writer and co producer)

Government Hooker (writer and co producer)

Heavy Metal Lover

Marry The Night (One of Gaga’s favorite songs as well)

The Edge Of Glory 

There’s more but these are my all time favorites 

Garibay on working with Gaga during BTW

Spoiler

Garibay: For every song, we averaged about 50 versions on the high side, because she was that much of a perfectionist. She wanted to give the best product possible to her fans. I would compare it to working on five albums at once. It was so much work, I didn’t sleep for a month, I would just take naps. And when she wasn't happy with any of the versions and she wanted to start over, I had to be the one to do it. It happened quite a few times -- it had to go through all those versions to evolve into the final product. Because in her head, it's like, "I want to hear the full rock version, I want to hear the full dance version, I want to hear the full techno version, I want to hear the full New Wave version." And once she hears and sees all the colors that she's working with, she can finally help paint that final picture. That's how it works. You can't get to the final point in her head without sketching each individual painting or trying each individual color. That way you know what the possibilities are.

 

[monketsharona 84,265]

Fernando is my second favorite Gaga producer

RedOne is still my fave, Bad Romance, Poker Face, ScheiBe, So Happy I Could Die, Judas, Paper Gangsta, Alejandro, Just Dance, Monster are still amongst my all time faves.

 

But honestly I feel like my all time top 20 of Gaga songs is 90% of RedOne and Garibay produced / written songs. Quite sad she hasn't reconnected with them for a few songs on her recent projects. There's a great alchemy there that just can't die

[Cookie Tookie 10,546]

RedOne and Fernando have produced her best, most timeless songs. And that’s fact.

[xoxo Craig 55,649]

Overrated imo

[Fish 6,157]

bllodpop can be very good too. ROM is timeless 

[Sorcerer92 837]

3 minutes ago, xoxo Craig said:

Overrated imo

Thats how I feel about Redone, tbh. Garibay has done magnificent work with LG, but I can see why he isn't everyone's favorite 

[Anderson123 38,787]

I do agree that some of her best songs are produced by him but still feel like he takes too much credit. He would not have been capable of making those songs without Gaga's vision and the way she's a perfectionist, that's just how she works and I admire it so much.

[Yxilon 5,248]

stream Kylie & Garibay 

[Lucas 27,367]

7 minutes ago, Kimmo said:

I know there’s been a little controversy between him, Gaga and DJWS after the BTW/ Madonna mess 

whut? I missed an episode lol

[Kimmo 81,120]

Just now, Fish said:

bllodpop can be very good too. ROM is timeless 

All her producers have done a very good job, is not a competition 

[monketsharona 84,265]

2 minutes ago, Kimmo said:

All her producers have done a very good job, is not a competition 

BloodPop is the definition of being underrated. He did amazing on Chromatica tbh. 

 

[Awakened M 3,056]

Heavy Metal Lover has been my all time favorite song before Chromatica was released.

[Kimmo 81,120]

6 minutes ago, Lucas said:

whut? I missed an episode lol

He just said he worked with Gaga to get coins and produced the BTW/Express Yourself mash up , monsters even called him a “rat” 

[xoxo Craig 55,649]

5 minutes ago, Sorcerer92 said:

Thats how I feel about Redone, tbh. Garibay has done magnificent work with LG, but I can see why he isn't everyone's favorite 

Both of them are overrated... like out of the songs mentioned in the OP, I only really love Bloody Mary... and that was co-produced with DJWS. I think DJWS, Bloodpop, Boys Noize, Burns, Tchami, and Madeon are better 

[Anderson123 38,787]

Dance In The Dark, Marry The Night, Heavy Metal Lover and The Edge of Glory are easily Gaga + Garibay but Government Hooker and Bloody Mary are more DJWS' production sound, I think. Even DJ Snake and Clinton Sparks were involved in those so lets not give him that much credit lol.