Rank Gaga’s Hits By Tier

[JRCF29 8,202]

16 minutes ago, selenalavigne said:

it's also 2 spots higher than Million Reasons on the Billboard Career History list. 

The Cure is like 5 spots higher than Rain on Me only because it’s been out longer 

Yoü and I has been out for 10 years almost and MR has been out for 4

[erotic4 557]

1 hour ago, BLACKPINK said:

1. Smashes: Bad Romance, Poker Face, Shallow

2. Trademark Hits: Just Dance, Born this Way

3. Hits: LoveGame, Paparazzi, Telephone, Alejandro, Judas, The Edge of Glory, You and I, Applause, Million Reasons, Rain On Me

4. The "Did Not Deserve This Treatment": Marry the Night, Perfect Illusion, The Cure, Stupid Love

5. The "Cannot Be Redeemed With Any Promo": G.U.Y., Joanne, John Wayne

6. The "Should have been a single": Always Remember Us This Way

the most accurate so far

[ArtpopAct2 2,672]

How is six week number one smash, most important song of her career in terms of its message Born This Way not a top tier one for some of y’all  gonna need some explanation

[selenalavigne 1,433]

1 minute ago, JRCF29 said:

The Cure is like 5 spots higher than Rain on Me only because it’s been out longer 

Yoü and I has been out for 10 years almost and MR has been out for 4

sissss it's about CHART HISTORY on the BILLBOARD HOT 100. Million Reasons is NO LONGER CHARTING. RAIN ON ME JUST STARTED CHARTING THAT'S WHY IT'S SO LOW. LMAOOO

[Ziggy 11,864]

12 minutes ago, JRCF29 said:

Ask those people to name the song the line comes from

Yeaaaahhhhh but I think it’s like if you play it in concert people will still go OMG YES, you know? It might take a little longer for that recognition with a Judas or DWUW (if she ever played it again which we know she won’t lol).

[JRCF29 8,202]

1 minute ago, Ziggy said:

Yeaaaahhhhh but I think it’s like if you play it in concert people will still go OMG YES, you know?

Lowkey hoping we don’t find out at TCB one of the only “usual setlist suspects” I’d be fine without 

[ArtpopAct2 2,672]

10 minutes ago, JRCF29 said:

Lowkey hoping we don’t find out at TCB one of the only “usual setlist suspects” I’d be fine without 

I agree with this. I love LoveGame but

1) It’s not as iconic as JD or Poker Face

2) It also has similar sounds to them, This puts it below paparazzi (the other not quite as big hit on TF) which sounds a bit more different.

3) TF is her oldest album, it’s singles have been performed the most and are the most burnt out. And taking into account the above, LoveGame is the one that’s the most obsolete.

[Luke78619 23,330]

I’m doing it based on my knowledge of the US performance and U.K. performance as well as a bit of Europe (ie just because MR went #4 in the US doesn’t mean it was a hit) 

TOP TIER: JD, PF, Paparazzi, BD, Telephone, Alejandro, BTW, TEOG, Shallow

GOOD TIER: LoveGame, Judas, Applause, ROM

OKAY TIER: Y&I, DWUW, MR, TC, SL

LOW TIER: MTN, GUY, PI

1 hour ago, joannesrats said:

Million Reasons is now one of Gaga's signature songs, everyone knows it and it's her signature ballad. It deserves to be in tier one

Not worldwide it’s not 

[BABYL0N 3,157]

The GP said YES:

Shallow, Bad Romance, Poker Face, Born This Way, Rain On Me, Alejandro, Telephone, Just Dance

The radio said YES:

Million Reasons, Applause, DWUW, The Cure, Stupid Love, ARUTW, TEOG, LoveGame

The fans said YASS: 

Judas, Marry The Night, Yoü and I, G.U.Y

Everyone said NO (unfortunately):

Perfect Illusion, Til It Happens To You, John Wayne, Joanne, Eh Eh 

[Ziggy 11,864]

20 minutes ago, JRCF29 said:

Lowkey hoping we don’t find out at TCB one of the only “usual setlist suspects” I’d be fine without 

Here’s my thing:

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

yes.