"Sine from above" was intented for Elton only 7 years ago

[palma 7,779]

Sine has that Euphoria-like Avicii  Swedish sound that was BIG in 2012-2015 so I can’t say I’m surprised but I’m guessing the lyrics and the overall theme still belong to Gaga and the OG demo was only a concept with perhaps the outro attached to it as an experimental moment 

[ice bear 1]

28 minutes ago, bleed dior said:

Sine From Above wishes to be as superior as The Cure. Sit down.

ew basic

[Tom Nook 37,805]

How can some of y’all not like the outro it’s like the best part it’s so unexpected  it reminds me of the production on this song

 

 

[SHALLOW 16,175]

I did say that it sounded dated 

[re di tutto 924]

5 minutes ago, ice bear said:

ew basic

You are 

[BetrayedSTAN 1,839]

13 minutes ago, M Monstre said:

Didn't RedOne help produce the song? Of course he's going to hype it up. He's not gonna say, "Yeah, it's just an okay song."

And no, the fans don't "have the right to ask for it." It's a scrapped song just like how any other song is a scrapped song. Do you have the "right" to ask for her entire library of scrapped songs? No. It's frankly none of our business. Would it be cool to hear other songs that didn't make it onto the albums? Sure, but we have no "right" to ask for it. 

It may be a really good song, but again, don't act like it's a pop culture messiah. 

Clearly this conversation is going nowhere.. and i have no energy to interact with u 

Have a nice day 

[Magui 2,625]

When a song is good, it remains good. No matter the years that go by and the years to come. It's good, simple.

[ProdigyARTPOP 3,899]

They redid the song, even though it was intended for Elton 7 years ago, he literally says they Skype’d his recording for the album version, like it’s not the same as the one presented to Elton 7 years ago,

before anyone runs off thinking Gaga exhausted this idea off someone else

[ice bear 1]

8 minutes ago, bleed dior said:

You are 

 free hostility is basic as well

i'm talking about the song not about you mr. short temper

[re di tutto 924]

2 minutes ago, ice bear said:

 free hostility is basic as well

i'm talking about the song not about you mr. short temper

Your avi is so cute.

[Antoni 5,332]

So you're telling me that the song that most of the album promo and the album cover itself is designed around was not even HER idea?

I am SINE-ing off for life.

[Helix 1,459]

1 minute ago, Timmers said:

So you're telling me that the song that most of the album promo and the album cover itself is designed around was not even HER idea?

I am SINE-ing off for life.

Just because an iteration of the song existed 7 years ago doesn't mean Gaga just copy & pasted it now, sometimes ideas & songs take a long time to come to fruition. Plus, it's entirely possible Gaga came up with the "sine" concept and they melded the demo to fit.

Stuff like this happens a lot, like the song Honey by Robyn took like 8 years to get finished and was passed around to various people but it doesn't make the song any less impactful. 

[Ziggy 11,327]

1 hour ago, Itsbrenda said:

Seven years?
 

How did this album take 2.5 years to make.. some of the songs sound like they where written for ‘The Fame’ like Plastic Doll.. 

 

love the album though, joint best with BTW for me

Because she’s been busy 

[Guest]

1 hour ago, moonsago said:

I love it but I still skip the end, its the one part I do not understand lol

it's when the signal splits in two 

[Gerrard174 527]

Clocking those who want elton off the track

This is Elton's track 3nded up as collabration with gaga. Pay that guy some respect at least.