P!nk or Xtina?

[hELXIG 43,047]

3 minutes ago, MonsterMom said:

 oh dear...I have so many questions: why is she trying to be destiny’s child? Why is she wearing a turtleneck? Why does she say “ sometime it BES like that”?  

Thank goodness she started doing things her way! 

1. She started in R&B and slowly evolved into the pop-ballad singer we know today

2. She was writing these songs in the 90's 

[River 117,090]

Not some of you trashing Can't Take Me Home

You Make Me Sick is a bop

[Pennywise 36,079]

Okay time to listen to Glitter in the Air and cry again brb 

 

Spoiler

that performance alone is BEYOND anything Xtina has ever done tbh 

 

[Taylucifer 5,154]

P!nk and I would fight but I know next to nothing about Xtina

[Franch Toast 26,879]

1 hour ago, Ronnie said:

Girl, this was P!nk’s debut single

 

I totally forgot this song existed. Wow, I'm totally transported. I saw Pink open for N'Sync way back when (2000? 2001?). Anyhow, I like them both. In my opinion, Christina's vocals are better (I think the first time I heard her was when she sang "Reflection" for Mulan), so I prefer her ballads over Pink's, but I slightly prefer Pink's bops, maybe because they play a lot of Pink songs in my aerobics classes. 

[Cookie Tookie 10,546]

1 hour ago, River said:

Not some of you trashing Can't Take Me Home

You Make Me Sick is a bop

I love that album so much. Don’t forget these iconic songs:

 

[Bubblegum Bitch 18,934]

Genie in a Bottle >>>

But Pink has good songs, too. 

[Monsterxo 1,499]

Pink

Personally not a fan of Christina's shrill voice. I respect her as an artist though.

[Ronnie 6,010]

54 minutes ago, Franch Toast said:

I totally forgot this song existed. Wow, I'm totally transported. I saw Pink open for N'Sync way back when (2000? 2001?). Anyhow, I like them both. In my opinion, Christina's vocals are better (I think the first time I heard her was when she sang "Reflection" for Mulan), so I prefer her ballads over Pink's, but I slightly prefer Pink's bops, maybe because they play a lot of Pink songs in my aerobics classes. 

Xtina was my bish back in the day, PERIDOT!

But, I may say, P!nk’s catalog be hittin different now. Like, that ish SLAPS! 

[Midnightrush891 727]

P!nk definitely won! I wonder if what keeps Xtina breathing is that she got the big part of Lady Marmalade?

[Midnightrush891 727]

2 hours ago, Gracious Gaga said:

 

Both had amazing debuts.

 

 

Both have amazing ballads.

 

 

Both have killer BOPS.

 

 

Both had successful duets.

 

 

And lets not forget when their paths crossed..

so who's it gonna be?

 

For me, P!nk takes the thrown.  If P!nk released the album "Stripped" instead of Xtina, I prob wouldn't listen to Xtina tbh. 

 

But wait get the party started was not P!nks debut 

[LoLaA 2,359]

P!nk

[Reject False Icons 4,770]

xtina, i am a big fan but I became one very late compared to the years she’s been active, also i grew up with Mi Reflejo 

Pink has excellent songs but somehow I get really bored listening to her albums entirely, so I’ve never finished one 

[Super 1,021]

i wouldnt say she's better (or worse) but i really like xtina.

[2School4Cool 6,449]

My name on GDD is after a lyric from a P!nk song for a reason. Lots of respect for Christina, she’s insanely talented, but P!nk is one of my all-time favorite artists and my absolute favorite live performer.