Gaga’s worst single in the last 7 years?

[Salvador Sequea 813]

15 hours ago, Mars said:

This remains one of her single greatest performances:

 

 I said almost 

Either way I wasn't talking about taste, but about the song's popularity. Which in the case of PI, is non-existing.

Yes PI is my 2nd favourite Gaga song, but she made it feel like MR was the lead of Joanne instead of PI

[EdgeofTeeth 1,934]

Perfect Illusion and Stupid Love were both bad single choices. I like both songs but I can’t even begin to understand why she chose them as lead singles 

PI is too loud/abrasive and doesn’t indicate the sound of Joanne at all, and SL just isn’t the “wow” song she needed to reintroduce her pop persona with (in my opinion).

[Ricardo 7,819]

G.U.Y it had already aged by the time it was released, also the video was a fcking mess

[Yxcvbnm 839]

At least PI's got a badass instrumental, that song is not that bad. A good filler. 

G. U. Y. With those fart sounds... 

But for me the absolutely winner of this competition is Stupid Love. I don't want to Drag it again... That song is cringey as fk and even the Million Reasons music video is better. 

[Guest]

I don’t get the dislike and straight up hate for Perfect Illusion? That song was so good for me. 

[petty 9,412]

57 minutes ago, Yxcvbnm said:

even the Million Reasons music video is better. 

NOW sis   

let’s not get crazy   

[Shaney 5,515]

On 4/13/2020 at 8:22 PM, Inferno said:

 

Perfect Illusion is the objective choice, its not a good song. Its lacking in lyricism arguably moreso than any of her other tracks. Its loud and obnoxious and its a bit abhorrent the way she took such a dope hypnotic track like the demo and absolutely ruined it. Honestly can't help but feel this out of the blue love for PI on here is solely fueled by contrarianism and has nothing to do with it being a good song. Because its not. I think you guys just like feeling like you're in on something that the GP is not lol another reason you all hate on GUY and The Cure. They're too seemingly "basic" for most of you despite the fact that theyre well produced little bangers that excel in what they were made to be.

That's a very strong opinion you have there, but your assumption about fans pretending to like it just isn't true. It's one of my favorite Gaga tracks. 

[old sanuk 366]

Perfect Illusion.  It sounds to me like vengeful primal scream therapy, and I don’t like to be around anyone publicly doing that; it’s hurtful, not kind.