Best 5th album from a main pop girl? Poll

[Gracious Gaga 17,163]

Alright everybody,

For the main pop girls who've been around long enough to put out 5 studio albums (excluding holiday albums or live albums) who's is your favorite?  The 5th album for many pop girls is a standout in their discography.  Forget about commercial success & charts- and put only music quality into consideration, as well as era visuals and performances/music videos/photoshoots!

Which album/era is the best?

CHOICES:

Erotica (1992) - Madonna

Butterfly (1997) - Mariah Carey

Blackout (2007) - Britney Spears

Funhouse (2008) - P!nk

Loud (2010) - Rihanna 

Beyonce (2013) - Beyonce

1989 (2014) - Taylor Swift

Joanne (2016) - Lady Gaga

Lust For Life (2017) - Lana Del Rey

Thank u, Next (2019) - Ariana Grande

[and i oop 1,360]

The only correct answer is Erotica by Madonna

[Biggest Bitch 5,230]

 

[ImCalledTT 120]

I do say this as a Taylor stan bear in mind, but 1989 is one of the most flawless pop projects in recent memory. 

 

Beyonce, Joanne and TU,N were all class too.

[KatieJudasGaga4 67,907]

Nevermind, I've heard all of them.

 

1. Joanne - Lady Gaga

2. Butterfly - Mariah Carey

3. Blackout - Britney Spears

4. Funhouse - Pink

5. 1989 - Taylor Swift

6. Beyonce - Beyonce

7. Erotica - Madonna

8. Loud - Rihanna

9. Lust for Life - Lana Del Rey

10. Thank U, Next - Ariana Grande

 

[blankpaper 21]

1989 was perfection 

[Gracious Gaga 17,163]

4 minutes ago, and i oop said:

The only correct answer is Erotica by Madonna

 

3 minutes ago, andrew23 said:

 

 

2 minutes ago, ImCalledTT said:

I do say this as a Taylor stan bear in mind, but 1989 is one of the most flawless pop projects in recent memory. 

 

Beyonce, Joanne and TU,N were all class too.

 

2 minutes ago, KatieJudasGaga4 said:

Nevermind, I've heard all of them.

 

1. Joanne - Lady Gaga

2. Butterfly - Mariah Carey

3. Blackout - Britney Spears

4. Funhouse - Pink

5. 1989 - Taylor Swift

6. Beyonce - Beyonce

7. Erotica - Madonna

8. Loud - Rihanna

9. Lust for Life - Lana Del Rey

10. Thank U, Next - Ariana Grande

 

 

Just now, blankpaper said:

1989 was perfection 

pull is up everyone !  

[2School4Cool 6,434]

I voted for Funhouse to show P!nk the love she deserves, Funhouse is a remarkable album , but Joanne is tied at number one for me. Two of my all-time favorites.

[Twitter 14]

In my humble opinion.

1. Beyoncé

2. Joanne

3. Loud

4. 1989

5. Blackout

6. thank u, next

7. Funhouse

The rest...

[Taide 5,789]

Classics like Erotica and Butterfly should never be mentioned next to those overhyped albums by gays.

[JRCF29 8,194]

Can we please have a little Gaga/P!nk collab, as a treat?

[blankpaper 21]

1 minute ago, 2School4Cool said:

I voted for Funhouse to show P!nk the love she deserves, Funhouse is a remarkable album , but Joanne is tied at number one for me. Two of my all-time favorites.

Pink is so underrated 

[Jose P 23,341]

 

None of those albums are as revolutionary and legendary as this one.

[ARTPOPSYCHOLOGY 6,270]

I’m sorry but from execution 1989 is the most perfect pop album era I’ve ever seen and I’m not even a huge taylor stan. Just stating facts 

[MingersPrayer 581]

Joanne is a really special album but in terms of career trajectory it was probably Taylor who gets it. Erotica is culturally significant too though.