Poker face back at No 10 on Dance/Electronic Song Sales chart

[GaGaAst 13,023]

1 minute ago, Floppy said:

I promise you if BR was a flop and not her most viewed video y'all wouldn't care. 

BR is my favourite song of All time. ALL TIME. 

And marry the night is my second favourite of all time. It flopped and is one of her least viewed video. 

I STAN IMPACT AND QUALITY 

[Floppy 7,951]

1 minute ago, GaGaAst said:

BR is my favourite song of All time. ALL TIME. 

And marry the night is my second favourite of all time. It flopped and is one of her least viewed video. 

I STAN IMPACT AND QUALITY 

I didn't mean you directly I mean the fanbase. 

[GaGaAst 13,023]

1 minute ago, Floppy said:

I didn't mean you directly I mean the fanbase. 

I know. But BR is just iconic 

[Floppy 7,951]

Just now, GaGaAst said:

I know. But BR is just iconic 

I disagree but that's just my own shitty opinion. I usually get dragged but oh well. 

[dynamite 58,611]

Just now, Floppy said:

I disagree but that's just my own shitty opinion. I usually get dragged but oh well. 

Wtf

At least you're aware 

[Hybrid AT 78]

16 minutes ago, BetrayedSTAN said:

Yet people still hating on redone lol 

Bloodpop could never 

Gaga+redone= timeless masterpiece 

I don't hate RedOne. I just think he's massively overrated within the fanbase. Like, you just look at his work with any other artist and you'll know he creates generic, bland pop music.

The harmonies and melodies that you hear in Gaga's music are mostly her own brainchild. She's just generous with the credits but I fully believe she's the one who comes with even the smallest details in her tracks. She's that talented.

It's not the producers who have made Gaga's work timeless. It's Gaga herself.

OT: An iconic track 

[BetrayedSTAN 1,839]

7 minutes ago, Floppy said:

I promise you if BR was a flop and not her most viewed video y'all wouldn't care. 

Even if it was a flop it will remain a great song cause simply u can't ignore its phenomenal production and genius lyrics .. just like marry the night .

[JustJames 950]

Just now, GaGaAst said:

I know. But BR is just iconic 

Agreed. 

When Gaga released singles and videos during TFM era in particular, they were moments in times I’ll never forget. I never looked at where the songs charged nor did I care.

Stupid Love is my first time dealing with the release of a Gaga track where people cling to charts and the opinions of the GP so hard. It’s a lot less fun than when we... just danced and it was all okay. Do-do-do...

[MonsterofFame 1,785]

2 minutes ago, HybridAT said:

The harmonies and melodies that you hear in Gaga's music are mostly her own brainchild. She's just generous with the credits but I fully believe she's the one who comes with even the smallest details in her tracks. She's that talented.

Then why hasn’t she been able to replicate her success like she did with RedOne?

Fact is, Gaga’s most successful songs were made with him.

[Curunir 7,510]

17 minutes ago, Doncho said:

YESSS! Flop Romance LOST

This made me choke on my water 

[BetrayedSTAN 1,839]

21 minutes ago, HybridAT said:

I don't hate RedOne. I just think he's massively overrated within the fanbase. Like, you just look at his work with any other artist and you'll know he creates generic, bland pop music.

The harmonies and melodies that you hear in Gaga's music are mostly her own brainchild. She's just generous with the credits but I fully believe she's the one who comes with even the smallest details in her tracks. She's that talented.

It's not the producers who have made Gaga's work timeless. It's Gaga herself.

Redone is famous for creating the sound that the artist wanted him to create and he's been saying this in almost of his interviews.. so if the sound is basic don't blame him .. also i recommend u to listen to some of the songs he produced for  porcelain black and alexandra burke etc ..

And if u say so why u think gaga failed to deliver a masterpieces like badromance/pokerface/alejandro etc ? Why she's still struggling to snatch a #1 with a dance pop song ? 

 

[Floppy 7,951]

8 minutes ago, BetrayedSTAN said:

Even if it was a flop it will remain a great song cause simply u can't ignore its phenomenal production and genius lyrics .. just like marry the night .

Well that's based on preference there are plenty of people that don't like both of those songs. I love MTN I think BR is good just not as good as everyone else I guess?

[Floppy 7,951]

4 minutes ago, BetrayedSTAN said:

Redone is famous for creating the sound that the artist wanted him to create .. so if the sound is basic don't blame him .. also i recommend u to listen to some of the songs he produced to porcelain black and alexandra burke etc ..

And if u say so why u think gaga failed to deliver a masterpieces like badromance/pokerface/alejandro etc ? Why she's still struggling to snatch a #1 dance pop song ? 

 

Because she's strayed FAR away from what's popular on the charts time and time again. Joanne happened during the PEAK on urban trap music clogging the charts. During ARTPOP her label ruined the era and forced the commercialization of the album and it all crashed and burned and troy abandoned her. that's why. 

 

 charts mean almost nothing to anyone these days except stans so...... and all of our faves are mostly free falling off the charts. 

[Floppy 7,951]

14 minutes ago, HybridAT said:

I don't hate RedOne. I just think he's massively overrated within the fanbase. Like, you just look at his work with any other artist and you'll know he creates generic, bland pop music.

The harmonies and melodies that you hear in Gaga's music are mostly her own brainchild. She's just generous with the credits but I fully believe she's the one who comes with even the smallest details in her tracks. She's that talented.

It's not the producers who have made Gaga's work timeless. It's Gaga herself.

OT: An iconic track 

Gaga's producers do have a habit of disappearing once she moves on to new producers....

[Ronk 14,762]