Jump to content
opinion

Why can’t we criticise Stupid Love?


Bobbins

Featured Posts

  • Replies 302
  • Created
  • Last Reply
2School4Cool
1 hour ago, Luc said:

I'm not the biggest fan of the song either, but I'm okay to keep that for myself, and I did need some time to see if it was simply going to be a song that would grow on me (like Applause and Born This Way). The song dropping on Spotify is not the thing to suddenly trigger me to start posting about it. I'm just not here to ruin the fun for other fans who do like it, which is what has happened every era so far tbh. I do like the direction Gaga seems to be going to, so I'm just waiting for the album. There's like at least 50 Gaga songs that I enjoy a lot, and I think the album could add another 10 to that. The lead single can never be liked by everybody. I loved Perfect Illusion, many others didn't, it failed with the GP, but I did enjoy the general positivity here regarding Stupid Love compared to Perfect Illusion, where it seems like every single user who disliked it felt the need to create their own thread.

See, we need more people like this on GGD. If you don’t like Stupid Love that’s totally fine. We can have differing opinions and be civil and kind and respectful. I personally adore Stupid Love but I totally respect your opinion. Unfortunately, all too many people are just spreading negativity, which is not at all the same as having a civil discussion.

See The Best In Everyone
Link to post
Share on other sites

Magui
7 minutes ago, 2School4Cool said:

See, we need more people like this on GGD. If you don’t like Stupid Love that’s totally fine. We can have differing opinions and be civil and kind and respectful. I personally adore Stupid Love but I totally respect your opinion. Unfortunately, all too many people are just spreading negativity, which is not at all the same as having a civil discussion.

Of course not... What we need is people taking a dump on her work, straight up calling it trash, trash and trash again. That's the civil, respectful and constructive criticism that irradiated from this thread yesterday. What we need is more of that. In fact more of that in a month when the album is here. I'm already forward seeing it.  So @Luc unfortunately that's not what we  need. Cynicism, my opinion is a fact and of course the more catty comments you can make the better is what we are looking for. 🙏🙌

Link to post
Share on other sites

ladygagafan1234

I see it as an intro to the era. It's not representative of the rest of the album. Applause was pretty basic & Perfect Illusion...

Link to post
Share on other sites

Suuus
31 minutes ago, Magui said:

Of course not... What we need is people taking a dump on her work, straight up calling it trash, trash and trash again. That's the civil, respectful and constructive criticism that irradiated from this thread yesterday. What we need is more of that. In fact more of that in a month when the album is here. I'm already forward seeing it.  So @Luc unfortunately that's not what we  need. Cynicism, my opinion is a fact and of course the more catty comments you can make the better is what we are looking for. 🙏🙌

I cant tell if your joking or not

Link to post
Share on other sites

He8myHEARTPOP
7 hours ago, Suuus said:

You didnt have to force yourself to like stupid love Why would you force yourself to like it if you dont like it you dont like it it that simple

I don’t have to, but I support Gaga in whatever her endeavors may be, like it or not - call it Stanning, - sort of like how a subject world have allegiance to a queen or queen in olden days I guess 🤷🏿‍♂️

Link to post
Share on other sites

Suuus
2 hours ago, He8myHEARTPOP said:

I don’t have to, but I support Gaga in whatever her endeavors may be, like it or not - call it Stanning, - sort of like how a subject world have allegiance to a queen or queen in olden days I guess 🤷🏿‍♂️

I still think you should not force yourself to like everthing gaga does you it doesnt mean that you dont support her and it doesnt make you less supportive its oke to not like everthing gaga does 

Link to post
Share on other sites

literallyFAD

because it's exhausting to see  u guys hurting your mind and soul

stay healthy in and outside

i'd rather die than living like a stone
Link to post
Share on other sites

gagaisitalian

i love the song. Wasn't impressed by the video and hate that she jumped on the "shot on iPhone" band wagon, but I guess a partnership with Apple is beneficial.

I really, really like the song and hope it climbs to #1, but I'm content with #5. I'm so ready for Chromatica! 

Link to post
Share on other sites

I listened to the leak, and I was hoping it would be slightly different, but overall I really am enjoying the song. It’s one of the only Gaga songs I’ve played on repeat. I usually like longer songs, but I feel the length of Stupid Love is perfect and it loops perfectly on repeat. It’s also the perfect song to hike and workout to. But I still can’t believe part of it leaked in August, and that she had it playing next to the pumpkin picture. I thought for sure that was a fake leak, and I don’t know how I didn’t notice the pumpkin picture until months later. :messga: I lurk this cult site all the time and I assume somebody made a thread instantly after that picture was posted. 

Link to post
Share on other sites

2School4Cool
8 hours ago, Suuus said:

I cant tell if your joking or not

Well @Magui liked my post so my guess is the comment was sarcastic, I could be wrong though :laughga:

See The Best In Everyone
Link to post
Share on other sites

Bobbins
13 hours ago, gagaisitalian said:

i love the song. Wasn't impressed by the video and hate that she jumped on the "shot on iPhone" band wagon, but I guess a partnership with Apple is beneficial.

I really, really like the song and hope it climbs to #1, but I'm content with #5. I'm so ready for Chromatica! 

It’s not climbing to number 1. The song is bombing on streaming sites and it’s sales have slowed down. The song is too in your face and loud and noisy. She needs to move onto the next single ASAP.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Animal Claws
8 minutes ago, Bobbins said:

It’s not climbing to number 1. The song is bombing on streaming sites and it’s sales have slowed down. The song is too in your face and loud and noisy. She needs to move onto the next single ASAP.

Leave. 

Link to post
Share on other sites

giskardsb
32 minutes ago, Bobbins said:

The song is too in your face and loud and noisy. 

Obviously Bad Romance and Telephone are such quiet little songs with minimal production.

Link to post
Share on other sites

andreas85
41 minutes ago, giskardsb said:

Obviously Bad Romance and Telephone are such quiet little songs with minimal production.

Though Bad Romance and Telephone or both much more imaginative songs and they are pop classics. No one is going to remember Stupid Love after ten years.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


×
×
  • Create New...