Jump to content
question

Poll: PI vs Shallow vs SL


Galagala

Poll: PI vs Shallow vs SL  

136 members have voted

  1. 1. Which one is the best lead single since Joanne?

    • Perfect Illusion
      29
    • Shallow
      42
    • Stupid Love
      60


Featured Posts

Economy

10 people actually voted for Perfect Illusion :deadbanana:

 

It's true what they say. There really is no accounting for taste :air:

Link to post
Share on other sites

migamiga

SL is more my taste although i do have issues with the basic lyrics and bland chorus, but production is great. PI also had really great production and probably my favorite gaga instrumental. shallow has the best lyrics of all three and interesting song structure

Link to post
Share on other sites

TheSlash

I remember when PI came out I wasn't really satisfied at first :noparty: . It grew on me after the album release and is in my Top 10 Gaga songs now :diane: .

Shallow was amazing, but as it was a movie and it was Gaga I kinda expected it to smash. To this day I'm still disappointed about that long build-up to Gaga's strong part ( it fits the movie's narrative perfectly, but doesn't do that for me as a song :saladga: ). I don't say I don't like the song, but the soundtrack had better songs on it ( ITA :giveup: )

Stupid Love on the other hand :giveup:  - it was the first lead single since Born This Way that I fell instantly in love with :heart: .

So SL is the clear winner for me :firega: .

Spoiler

Expecting a bunch of sad reactions bc of my comment about Shallow :lolly: 

 

Ew, David!
Link to post
Share on other sites

NewUsername

They're all so different! It feels 'rude' to say anything else than Stupid Love right now, on release day, but Shallow is the best song of those 3 listed of course.

Link to post
Share on other sites

AzeaIia Banks

I pick PI because you can spell 'pen¡s' with it, and i also like pen¡s

Gaga please release Red Flame and Ratchet
Link to post
Share on other sites

Shallow

When you compare it to Stupid Love, the drop in music quality is huge.

Stupid Love sounds like crap commercial pop, the kind of pop Katy Perry, Kesha, Ava make.

Link to post
Share on other sites

WORLDofGAGA

Perfect illusion took me a while to get into, now it’s one of my favourite Gaga songs. Stupid love was like hmm for listen then it grew on me really quick and it’s catchy. Shallow I love and grew on me more and more, it’s a hit!!

@W0RLDofGAGA
Link to post
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

×
×
  • Create New...